Tonight I'm doing a comparison between my longtime favorite Burley blend, Haunted Bookshop, and it's cousin Pegasus; the latter of which I've never had before tonight. I'm smoking them both back to back in the Dr. Grabow Lark, since the small bowl is great for sampling.
My initial impression is that Pegasus is basically just Haunted Bookshop with unsweetened Black Cavendish instead of Perique. The only things I've ever disliked about Haunted Bookshop are how harsh it is on my throat towards the last half of the bowl and that the nicotine content is a little stronger than I generally prefer, and Pegasus solves both of those problems for me. I think I could easily smoke Pegasus all day and never get a sore throat or nicotine sickness, whereas Haunted Bookshop is very much a "once a day only" smoke for me if I don't want to get a sore throat.
On the flip side, without the subtle spice of Perique to liven things up the overall flavor profile of Pegasus is a little bland in comparison to Haunted Bookshop and I wouldn't mind Pegasus having just a little more Vitamin N. I think I'm going to have to smoke Pegasus at least a good 4 or 5 more times to really make up my mind about whether or not I like it better than Haunted Bookshop, since they're so similar in a lot of ways but very different in others. Flavor and tin note wise I definitely prefer Haunted Bookshop, but I think my throat would be a lot happier if I picked Pegasus for my usual rotation instead.