***What Are You Smoking, November 2025?***

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

JimInks

Sultan of Smoke
Aug 31, 2012
70,138
801,860
I've passed the quarter mark of my last smoke of the day, which is Wilke Surbrug’s Crystal Palace in a dark brown smooth straight post-WW2 LHS Certified Purex 79 bulldog with a nickel ferrule and tenon with a black vulcanite saddle stem. Still busy downloading and labeling Tomato the Brave and Norton the Nosey play photos. I haven't gotten to the best ones yet, but here are a few of them.
LHS Certified Purex 79 bulldog .jpg
Tomato_Norton7TPaw.jpg
Tomato_Norton8TPaw.jpg
Tomato_Norton9.jpg
Tomato_Norton12Kitchen.jpg
 

Benedict Munsinger

Part of the Furniture Now
Nov 6, 2024
532
10,159
54
Manchester
It’s a fine smoke and a staple in my cellar. I find the Perique used in TH is really to my liking and very plummy, much more than Cabbies or St James and it ages very well.
Thanks for sharing your take on it🤝. For me, the Perique in Chacom 4 comes through much more subtly — I get a light spice and a touch of dark fruit, but not that fuller “plummy” profile you describe. It may simply be a matter of batch variation or how our palates read the balance between the Virginias and Perique. In any case, I agree that it’s a well-made blend, and it certainly has good aging potential.
 

Benedict Munsinger

Part of the Furniture Now
Nov 6, 2024
532
10,159
54
Manchester
Thanks for sharing your take on it🤝. For me, the Perique in Chacom 4 comes through much more subtly — I get a light spice and a touch of dark fruit, but not that fuller “plummy” profile you describe. It may simply be a matter of batch variation or how our palates read the balance between the Virginias and Perique. In any case, I agree that it’s a well-made blend, and it certainly has good aging potential.
A small addition. And yes! Chacom 4 doesn't even come close to comparing to Telegraph Hills. (Personal opinion).
 

Benedict Munsinger

Part of the Furniture Now
Nov 6, 2024
532
10,159
54
Manchester
Nording Compass. Of the current Robert McConnell Heritage line, Boutique Blend is hands-down the most technique-sensitive blend they offer. It’s not faulty tobacco and it’s not “bad” — it’s simply a very light, oriental-forward English that punishes you immediately for anything faster than a slow sip. Push it even a little and it hisses, steams, and turns sharp/acrid in the mouth. Avoid thin-walled pipes completely — they heat up too fast and make the problem ten times worse. Stick to thicker walls (group 4–5 billiards, pots, thick dublins) where the briar can absorb and dissipate the heat. Dry it 15–20 minutes, use a bigger/heavier pipe, breathe it instead of puffing, and it’s excellent — creamy, peppery, subtle smoke. Rush it or put it in a thin bowl and you’ll hate life. Classic oriental behavior, just more unforgiving than most of the other RMC offerings.
IMG_6342.jpeg
 

Choatecav

Lifer
Dec 19, 2023
1,894
18,314
Middle Tennessee
Nording Compass. Of the current Robert McConnell Heritage line, Boutique Blend is hands-down the most technique-sensitive blend they offer. It’s not faulty tobacco and it’s not “bad” — it’s simply a very light, oriental-forward English that punishes you immediately for anything faster than a slow sip. Push it even a little and it hisses, steams, and turns sharp/acrid in the mouth. Avoid thin-walled pipes completely — they heat up too fast and make the problem ten times worse. Stick to thicker walls (group 4–5 billiards, pots, thick dublins) where the briar can absorb and dissipate the heat. Dry it 15–20 minutes, use a bigger/heavier pipe, breathe it instead of puffing, and it’s excellent — creamy, peppery, subtle smoke. Rush it or put it in a thin bowl and you’ll hate life. Classic oriental behavior, just more unforgiving than most of the other RMC offerings.
View attachment 431909
Great description of the experience!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.