A pipe's beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
Such huge victories just make one feel naughty..., like getting away with not just one cookie, but the entire cookie jar, with none the wiser. What I'm smoking as I type is one such pipe, a Savinelli Punto Oro straight apple(having some Brown Clunee in it by the way, to stay on topic). I got it last month for 23 smackers-- was badly caked, had a sizeable gash on the rim from careless reaming(which has been covered up just from excess alcohol "restaining" it during S+A treatment), and had a wicked Cherry cough syrup ghost which I presumed to be Captain Black, and a yellow oxidized stem. Did my best to restore it with my absolutely minimal resources, and did okay I'd say-- chasing embers' toothpaste trick worked pretty well. Currently trying to re-break it in, hoping it performs well.