Got up stupid early and finished 18 holes before 11:15 - rewarding myself now with a little compare and contrast: McC Frog Morton on the Bayou in a Bullfrog "Gumnut" vs a Nate King meerschaum prince vs a Scottie Piersel morta chimney-dog (results after the jump):
Gumnut v Meer Prince seems like a reasonable comp as they are roughly similar in bowl size/shape - taste seemed "cleaner" to my palette from the meerschaum, marginally so though.
The Morta Chimney-dog probably smoked the best. Taste-wise closer to the meerschaum than the briar but much cooler. I suspect the shape/size/depth will play a lot into that. Would be curious to get a couple of pipes that are exactly the same shape and size but in different materials to do a direct comparisons. ... Maybe a new project...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b151b/b151b571618dcc53a82e0d35482e5ebb11ae1adf" alt="o4JFrYoh.jpg"
Gumnut v Meer Prince seems like a reasonable comp as they are roughly similar in bowl size/shape - taste seemed "cleaner" to my palette from the meerschaum, marginally so though.
The Morta Chimney-dog probably smoked the best. Taste-wise closer to the meerschaum than the briar but much cooler. I suspect the shape/size/depth will play a lot into that. Would be curious to get a couple of pipes that are exactly the same shape and size but in different materials to do a direct comparisons. ... Maybe a new project...