Nice restoration work, Al. I think you are right about the billiard being a Charatan second. Back in the early 70's, I bought two Charaton seconds from a pipe shop on Cape Cod. The first one I bought is a tan sandblast in a shape Charatan calls "the Ton". On a second trip, I bought a black sandblast in a shape called "Gilpin" Both shapes are, as far as I know, unique to Charatan. The only markings on them are "made in" over "London England". I compared the lettering to six of the major English pipe brands. It matches the lettering on 1960's era Lane era Charatans. It also matches the lettering on a GBD from before the merger with Comoy, but that could be because they used the same source for their stamps.