US Pipe Tobacco Companies ?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
22,960
58,323
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Okay where do you source Yenidje?
You might try here.

 

cosmicfolklore

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 9, 2013
36,457
89,248
Between the Heart of Alabama and Hot Springs NC
Just saw the bit about flakes. Of course Sutliff could make flakes, and a frickin' plug if it came to that. I've see those big solid pressed 5 lb bricks, and have gotten a sawn off chunk off of one of them as a gift. Stop with the BS and move the hell on. It's OVER!

The whole discussion I was having was not what all did they do, but what were they known for.
So, which flakes sold under their name did they make themselves?
 
  • Like
Reactions: telescopes

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
22,960
58,323
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
The whole discussion I was having was not what all did they do, but what were they known for.
So, which flakes sold under their name did they make themselves?
OK, that's different. They made flakes for Peretti and others , but not, with the exception of Cringle Flake, and Krampusnacht, can I think of any flake for which they are famous. Honestly who cares? Making a famous flake is a measure of what?

On the other hand, their match blends were highly successful and much loved, as were their aromatics. Everybody does something. Few do it well.
 

cosmicfolklore

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 9, 2013
36,457
89,248
Between the Heart of Alabama and Hot Springs NC
OK, that's different.
Yeh, that was Crash's hangup. We PM'd also while discussing. It's easy to miss those first few posts that explains what I am talking about. Of course I fully understand that they did a whole lot more than what the average guy would see.
It does baffle me that Sutliff had the capacity to make real flakes, and yet they didn't make them for C&D, McC, nor their namesake... which left the 3 biggies in the US without a genuine European style flake on their catalogs... except the one from STD
 
  • Like
Reactions: sablebrush52

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
You might try here.

Yes, I saw that, but thank you for the reminder. When the time comes to reformulate and make more of my own blends, I imagine I will be getting into the whole leaf cutting thing. Thanks for the link.

As you said, it's over now. However, I did get some interesting plugs and flakes from Sutliff in years past. As you said, they were not the most well known, but they were interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nevaditude

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
22,960
58,323
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Yeh, that was Crash's hangup. We PM'd also while discussing. It's easy to miss those first few posts that explains what I am talking about. Of course I fully understand that they did a whole lot more than what the average guy would see.
It does baffle me that Sutliff had the capacity to make real flakes, and yet they didn't make them for C&D, McC, nor their namesake... which left the 3 biggies in the US without a genuine European style flake on their catalogs... except the one from STD
I don't know the full extent of Sutliff's involvement with McClelland, other than supplying some component tobaccos, like Latakia. Who knows if they did fabricate flakes for them or not, besides Mike McNeil. As I recall, C&D did buy McClelland's press, but that's "insider" hearsay, not anything I could verify. Not that I would be that interested in any case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: woodsroad

Briarcutter

Lifer
Aug 17, 2023
2,085
11,620
U.S.A.
Since I know nothing about tobacco,other than smoking it,here's my ignorant opinion. Tobaccos like Yenidje are not "blended" they are grown. Sutliff didn't grow tobacco. The growers will still be wanting to sell their product and they probably don't care who buys it. Sure it has to be processed but if there's money to be made, someone will pick up the importing of it, if...there's money to be made. I suppose about anyone could import these tobaccos, as long as you had the connections the money and wanted to jump through the legal hoops. Telescopes, you could be the Yenidje king of the USA😁
 

dd57chevy

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 7, 2023
722
2,477
Iowa
Since I know nothing about tobacco,other than smoking it,here's my ignorant opinion. Tobaccos like Yenidje are not "blended" they are grown. Sutliff didn't grow tobacco. The growers will still be wanting to sell their product and they probably don't care who buys it. Sure it has to be processed but if there's money to be made, someone will pick up the importing of it, if...there's money to be made. I suppose about anyone could import these tobaccos, as long as you had the connections the money and wanted to jump through the legal hoops. Telescopes, you could be the Yenidje king of the USA😁
Agree 100%* . While I don't know the exact number , there have to be dozens of profitable tobacconists/online vendors in the US .
For example , Steve at Peretti's . Imagine dozens of Steves with thousands of dollars in their fists yelling "HEY , WE NEED A SUPPLIER ! ANYBODY WANT TO MAKE SOME MONEY ?!?!? HELLO ?!?!?

No , it wouldn't be easy . No business is easy to set up & run .

*Please don't give me the shallow "Well , why don't you do it ?" All I know about tobacco is how to load a bowl & light it .......... :sher:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Briarcutter

Zamora

Lifer
Mar 15, 2023
1,150
2,989
Olympia, Washington
I've heard rumblings (though I realize that coming from random forum members could be as solid info as the rumblings that come not from our mouths but another orifice.. 😅) that the next leaf type to take a real nosedive in availability, quality, and variety (a-la Latakia) is going to be Turkish/Orientals...

I've also heard that this was one of the reasons speculated for being a coffin nail in the old Daughter's and Ryan (people may forget how one of their biggest bulks used to be Ramback which was considered one of the finest Turkish bulks around by many)...

Also been hearing that the more boutique varietals like Yendje have been drying up as well (perhaps another nail in the coffin of STG axing all the Russ Oulette H&H Balkans) though that one's pure speculation on my part...

... In your experience do you see any of this to be true?


It would certainly make sense to me based on the market trends. The funny thing is (another tangent that probably deserves it's own thread) that we hear SO MUCH about what an endangered species Perique is but imho that seems to be alot of bluster... sure it's a labor intensive process but it's made in this country and has seen alot of investment and protection both by Mark Ryan and C&D respectively. Hell, to me it seems like we're probably in the golden age of VaPer's... it seems almost every new blend (including the lion's share of new and/or limited releases) are essentially just new VaPer's...
Idk... this is all just the absurdities that echo through my skull. But very curious as to what actual insiders like you or @crashthegrey think about it though :)
I don't remember the name but Stokkebye used to have a straight Oriental blend and it was discontinued a couple years ago. It was pretty good
 
  • Like
Reactions: NookersTheCat

NookersTheCat

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 10, 2020
746
3,686
NEPA
I don't remember the name but Stokkebye used to have a straight Oriental blend and it was discontinued a couple years ago. It was pretty good
Yes! It was called PS84 Turkish Blend... I have a pound that's going on a decade old socked away. Up until a few weeks ago Newminster also had a No. 84 Turkish (All copies of PS) but now that they're done, so is that blend along with nearly all their others.
 

NookersTheCat

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 10, 2020
746
3,686
NEPA
Agree 100%* . While I don't know the exact number , there have to be dozens of profitable tobacconists/online vendors in the US .
For example , Steve at Peretti's . Imagine dozens of Steves with thousands of dollars in their fists yelling "HEY , WE NEED A SUPPLIER ! ANYBODY WANT TO MAKE SOME MONEY ?!?!? HELLO ?!?!?

No , it wouldn't be easy . No business is easy to set up & run .

*Please don't give me the shallow "Well , why don't you do it ?" All I know about tobacco is how to load a bowl & light it .......... :sher:
Yeah I think the main issue now is with regulation. If this was any other industry things would look alot different... but the thing is who wants to put up hundreds of thousands to get into a space where once some beurocrat notices you sends a letter saying "Hey we're gonna need $1M per blend to test and its gonna take years and you can't sell anything til it's over and once it's done probably half or more will be banned"

Wertzel himself even said that basically every limited and post 2013 blend Sutliff was selling was being done on a "ask for forgiveness rather than permission" basis.
The entrepreneurial spirit only works if you have a free market... currently we have a market (especially in tobacco) where sneezing the wrong way will land you in jail or bankrupt if your company name isn't Altria... aka, the only one with enough $ to buy the yachts our benevolent overlords require to allow us plebs to produce for them...

Add in being a niche market that is profitable but really only holding steady at best growth-wise (any bank lending money today wants to see double-digit market growth per year) and it's just a really high barrier to entry with few ever older people who understand the industry.

There may very well be 10's or even hundreds of thousands of folks in this country that want luxury pipe tobacco and are willing to pay for it... just like there's millions of folks in this country that want high quality, pure cocaine and are willing to pay for it... but as long as the government's response to supplying both in quantity is "30 years and $500,000" then you're gonna be stuck buying both from "your guy" in a walmart parking lot, if you can even find it at all... 😅
 

sardonicus87

Lifer
Jun 28, 2022
1,818
16,252
38
Lower Alabama
Agree 100%* . While I don't know the exact number , there have to be dozens of profitable tobacconists/online vendors in the US .
For example , Steve at Peretti's . Imagine dozens of Steves with thousands of dollars in their fists yelling "HEY , WE NEED A SUPPLIER ! ANYBODY WANT TO MAKE SOME MONEY ?!?!? HELLO ?!?!?

No , it wouldn't be easy . No business is easy to set up & run .

*Please don't give me the shallow "Well , why don't you do it ?" All I know about tobacco is how to load a bowl & light it .......... :sher:
Well, a lot of people talk and don't know what they're talking about or oversimplify things.

Ernie of Watch City not long ago did an interview on a podcast and explained they don't work with whole leaf because they'd need to be a much larger outfit with more staff for it to be feasible.

I'm paraphrasing the gist of what I remember of the 5 minutes that I watched, but in the USA, if you get whole leaf and are a commercial business, you need a separate room to store it that's bonded to something like $1 million, and you have to meticulously record everything in and out with only licensed people going in and be subject to monthly inspections from the FDA or something.

So yeah, the idea that any individual could just start up a business in their basement for getting/importing whole leaf is kind of stupid. Good luck getting that million dollar loan to start your small business?

So yeah, if there's money to be made AND someone has the money needed to make the money... but people with money don't typically gamble on low-profit stuff, especially when they don't need to because they already have all the money.

It would take basically another STG, or just some dude that's loaded and is passionate specifically about tobacco. Reality is a bitch.

Video in question, talks about it within in the first 5 minutes so you don't have to hunt for it: