Top 5 must try Pipe tobaccos

[perdurabo]

Oh yea, Gravity fill that pipe with Gaslight.

 

[thomasmartin]

In no particular order:

Dunhill Early Morning Pipe

Dunhill London Mixture

Dunhill Standard mixture

Dunhill My Mixture 965

Dunhill Nightcap

 

[deathmetal]

Did someone mention Dunhill Royal Yacht?
No party is complete without it!

 

[phantomwolf]

Did someone mention Dunhill Royal Yacht?

That is a great first bowl of tobacco haha

 

[deathmetal]

It is amazing.
Second best is the dried flesh of my enemies, mixed with Early Morning Pipe.

 

[hillbillyjosh]

Some Old Codger Blend (thanks Tom, and Beefeater) I've enjoyed SWR Aromatic. Gotta try Carter Hall for myself

1Q

Mac Baren Vanilla Cream

Stokkebye LTF

Seven Seas Black
My top 5 out of the 20 or so I've tried, so far.

 

[hillbillyjosh]

I know who the Dunhill fan boy is around here.

 

[captpat]

Carter Hall

Aged Burley Flake

Squadron Leader

McClellands 2015 Va Flake

Frog Morton Cellar
Hard to select 5 from the numerous good blends available, these I've found to be consistent tin to tin or pouch to pouch.

 

[mawnansmiff]

Ok, I'll bite. In no particular order...
1/ Full Virginia Flake (or Plug)
2/ St. James Flake (or Plug)
3/ Westmorland Slices
4/ Bold Kentucky
5/ Dark Flake (or Plug)
...those are the unflavoured ones, for flavoured it would be...
1/ Condor Flake (or Plug)
2/ Erinmore Flake (or Plug)
3/ Royal Yacht
4/ Mellow Virginia
5/ Wallace Flake
Regards,
Jay.

 

[hillbillyjosh]

Funny how your list changes.
Old Dark Fired

PS LTF

Plum Pudding SR

1Q/BCA 1:1

Carmel Rush