Tobacco Blend of your Dreams

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
45,322
119,737
I think the tobacco that I envision as the perfect tobacco for me would be if the Virginia's and perique in Rouxgaroux were somehow components in some sort of Navy Flake. Maybe a little Burley in there with some molasses and rum. It could also be horrible.
Mix it 50/50 with Double Barrel.
 

boston

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 27, 2018
561
1,284
Boston
For over 20 years I didn't purchase Frog Morton. Instead I explored everything that appeared top shelf and harder to get. When I got word that Frog was gonna be extinct, I purchased a few tins. Like $8 a tin at the time. And then I tried it.

Well, I was proved me wrong for being a snob. I love a dozen or so blends, including 1792 at a different end of the spectrum, but Frog is a special perfect tobacco to me. Gets my vote, and I've spent some time acquiring a reasonable stash.

It's a bit moody. 1792 and a couple of others are forgiving, they always deliver. Frog only works for me when I'm calm enough to enjoy a slow smoke. If I'm in a rush or stressed it's flat and not swell. Otherwise, it's excellent in all ways from flavor to burn to a fine ash. Weird.
 

rmpeeps

Lifer
Oct 17, 2017
1,147
1,847
San Antonio, TX
These blenders know what they are doing so I leave the hefty lifting to them. I have never messed with blends like so many people do. I think it is a waste of good tobacco, as a blender knows the right percentages how long to age which blends and for how long.

I also think it is disrespectful to the original blender. Imagine if some quack like us went into the Coke factory and started messing with their blends, same thing in my book. Call ne old fashioned in this way, I go with the guy who brought me, not a guy cheapening his blend . That is just me, I understand peoples desire to mess with peoples blend but it is not for me.
Gosh, I guess you never added any rum or bourbon to a glass of Coke….?
Here’s one I did a small 8oz test batch of which lasted a few years. After the first year I did a 2lb batch that ended up lasting 16 years in various jars.
October Skys was pure ambrosia.
2X - McC 5100 Red Cake
2X - McC 22
0.75x - St James Perique
 

DanWil84

Lifer
Mar 8, 2021
1,691
12,665
40
The Netherlands (Europe)
I think im in the "let the blender blend" camp. I do have notion how I would blend a blend, but I would not be able to discern that a blend needs a x amount of y tobacco or tone down tobacco y and replace the same amount with tobacco z. I compare it with picking wine and beer, I let the waiter or shop assistant (I do know where to go, these people have a lot of knowledge on their product) decide what fits the bill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JOHN72

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
45,322
119,737
Gosh, I guess you never added any rum or bourbon to a glass of Coke….?
Here’s one I did a small 8oz test batch of which lasted a few years. After the first year I did a 2lb batch that ended up lasting 16 years in various jars.
October Skys was pure ambrosia.
2X - McC 5100 Red Cake
2X - McC 22
0.75x - St James Perique
I went 50/50 with McC 40th Anniversary and Sutliff TS24 that was amazing.?
 

SmokeClouds

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 7, 2019
164
382
New York
Gosh, I guess you never added any rum or bourbon to a glass of Coke….?
Here’s one I did a small 8oz test batch of which lasted a few years. After the first year I did a 2lb batch that ended up lasting 16 years in various jars.
October Skys was pure ambrosia.
2X - McC 5100 Red Cake
2X - McC 22
0.75x - St James Perique
Sounds like a great blend. Hope you have some left.
 

SmokeClouds

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 7, 2019
164
382
New York
For over 20 years I didn't purchase Frog Morton. Instead I explored everything that appeared top shelf and harder to get. When I got word that Frog was gonna be extinct, I purchased a few tins. Like $8 a tin at the time. And then I tried it.

Well, I was proved me wrong for being a snob. I love a dozen or so blends, including 1792 at a different end of the spectrum, but Frog is a special perfect tobacco to me. Gets my vote, and I've spent some time acquiring a reasonable stash.

It's a bit moody. 1792 and a couple of others are forgiving, they always deliver. Frog only works for me when I'm calm enough to enjoy a slow smoke. If I'm in a rush or stressed it's flat and not swell. Otherwise, it's excellent in all ways from flavor to burn to a fine ash. Weird.
Always a pleasant surprise to find a new blend that 'clicks', especially in time to build a stash while available.
On another note, do you like 1792 fresh or with some age?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JOHN72

Eye-level

Starting to Get Obsessed
Dec 12, 2021
213
2,766
Tulsa Oklahoma
These blenders know what they are doing so I leave the hefty lifting to them. I have never messed with blends like so many people do. I think it is a waste of good tobacco, as a blender knows the right percentages how long to age which blends and for how long.

I also think it is disrespectful to the original blender. Imagine if some quack like us went into the Coke factory and started messing with their blends, same thing in my book. Call ne old fashioned in this way, I go with the guy who brought me, not a guy cheapening his blend . That is just me, I understand peoples desire to mess with peoples blend but it is not for me.
I go down to Ted's Pipe shop and buy the house blends. Man who owns the place has forgotten more than I'll ever learn about tobacco and pipes. I trust him and he is just great. I do not buy tins...I just go down to the tobacco shop and grab a couple oz. Of whatever he makes...I'd rather spend my time smoking it than jacking with it. :)