I have a story of something I experienced awhile back.
My wife and I were at a local junk store. It's absolutely huge, but always picked over by the owner and his friends. I'm not going to blow him up but he has an ebay shop where he sells ALL the good stuff. The things on his shelves are garage sale type items....usually junk. He does have some tools and such at good prices. When I need a "once in a blue moon" tool, I go there....like a ball joint pickle fork.
Anyways, we were there looking around and I found a Wellington pipe. One of the "imposter" Peterson System pipes. They are good pipes, and probably as good as modern Petersons, but they ain't Petersons.
It was WELL used but still had some years of use left.
It was in his glass case where he sits, where the good stuff is.
There was no price, so I asked.
He said this was a VERY rare pipe made from REAL briar, which is rare....and he had $275 on the pipe but was up to haggle. I did not insult him with a $25 offer, I just said I would pass.
I know those Wellingtons go for $25-$50 all day long in good shape. This pipe was this side of acceptable.
Very dull finish, brown oxidized Vulcanite stem, a charred rim, deep tooth marks top and bottom, and scratches, dings and fills galore.
With some work it would be a good smoker, but I thought he would say $10 and it's yours.....which I would have done.
He usually has some old beater pipe's for $10-$20, but this Wellington apparently was a masterpiece.