Old Spice, Clubman or Speick unless it’s something I’ve blended myself.
If you REALLY want to go down an aftershave rabbit hole there’s a wet shaving forum where a very long thread investigated whether Old Spice has changed formulation. It eventually involved the use of either a mass spectrometer or gas chromatograph. No kidding.
Yes. It looks like the thread is still active. Amazing.
I have both vintage and current Old Spice. They’re different but I don’t know how much of the difference is age and if there was any meaningful reformulation. Both are pleasant.
Geo. F. Trumper's shave cream with a badger hair brush and Old Spice afterwards. Occasionally I alternate with English Leather. Those are the only ones my wife will let me use, though I must say she responds very positively to them! I do have a tiny bottle of cologne my daughter gave me called "ceci n'est pas une pipe".