That Sublime Smoke

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,662
31,237
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
A truly sublime smoke is more than just the smoke. It's when other aspects such as mood, a great meal, a great day or great company come together to combine with a superb smoke. Most of my smokes are really good, is rare they're otherwise. I think the term sublime may be thrown about a bit too carelessly.
it's certainly a rare treat. And the smoke it's self is only one tiny aspect a critical aspect. Yes everything has to be perfect and that perfection has to be subtle yet obvious at the same time.
 

musicman

Lifer
Nov 12, 2019
1,119
6,058
Cincinnati, OH
As to the sublime smoke, I have one of those every week or so, and Wow! It's part of the reason I'm in this hobby. I mean, by this point I've developed the skills to have nearly every smoke be good, or very good, but it's an intersection of circumstances (blend choice, pipe choice, packing, dryness of the tobacco, what I ate earlier, weather conditions, etc.) that really allow the smoke to achieve the next level.
 

lawdawg

Lifer
Aug 25, 2016
1,792
3,805
I think there is some objective scientific way to get and repeat the "sublime smoke" and that it isn't just a state of mind or dependent upon other extraneous factors. I'm getting better at it but certainly have not mastered it. It's mostly about getting the ideal moisture level and packing firmness for any given tobacco, IMO. It also goes without saying that a well-engineered pipe is required so as to not inhibit the experience with gurgles, excess moisture, etc.

I've been getting some pretty sublime smokes with Capstan Blue and with GLP Westminster. Both are easy to smoke and forgiving, and have fairly complex flavors, at least enough to get multiple little nuances in each blend.
 

musicman

Lifer
Nov 12, 2019
1,119
6,058
Cincinnati, OH
I think there is some objective scientific way to get and repeat the "sublime smoke" and that it isn't just a state of mind or dependent upon other extraneous factors. I'm getting better at it but certainly have not mastered it. It's mostly about getting the ideal moisture level and packing firmness for any given tobacco, IMO. It also goes without saying that a well-engineered pipe is required so as to not inhibit the experience with gurgles, excess moisture, etc.

I've been getting some pretty sublime smokes with Capstan Blue and with GLP Westminster. Both are easy to smoke and forgiving, and have fairly complex flavors, at least enough to get multiple little nuances in each blend.
While that is true, I also believe that environmental and psychological circumstances play a large part in our enjoyment of any pleasurable activity. For instance, I am a beer snob through and through, but the best beer of my life came about 20 years ago, with my best friend, after a long day of skiing. It was a Newcastle Brown Ale, usually not really a favorite, but under those circumstances (thirsty, a little cold, in need of nourishment, and with one of my favorite person) the sum of all variables far exceeded their perceived value. My buddy and I (who have both probably had exactly zero newcastles since then) still talk about that beer. Similarly, my wife's best beer of all time was a Bud Lite, enjoyed on a bus after a day of whitewater rafting on the New River in West Virginia.

I suppose what I am saying is that no matter how hard we try as humans to distill such experiences into purely objective terms, the subjective variables often play a large part in our enjoyment (or lack thereof) of such experiences.
 
Jan 28, 2018
13,915
155,568
67
Sarasota, FL
I think there is some objective scientific way to get and repeat the "sublime smoke" and that it isn't just a state of mind or dependent upon other extraneous factors. I'm getting better at it but certainly have not mastered it. It's mostly about getting the ideal moisture level and packing firmness for any given tobacco, IMO. It also goes without saying that a well-engineered pipe is required so as to not inhibit the experience with gurgles, excess moisture, etc.

I've been getting some pretty sublime smokes with Capstan Blue and with GLP Westminster. Both are easy to smoke and forgiving, and have fairly complex flavors, at least enough to get multiple little nuances in each blend.

I agree that your smoking technique, tobacco prep, tobacco choice, pipe choice, etc. can lead to many if not most smokes being superb. By my definition however, sublime brings those other psychological factors I mentioned into play. Just semantics really and you're more than welcome to your definition of sublime. When I think of sublime, totally relaxed and near spiritual state come to mind. I'm smoking a fantastic bowl of Wessex Gold Virginia Flake right now. It's checking off all the boxes. But I'm also doing so while doing some work, mixing in phone calls and posting here. So to me at least, it isn't reaching the sublime level.

If we must "devolve" into the sexual analogy, think of it like this. A great bowl of tobacco that doesn't reach the sublime level would be like an excellent one night stand. Physically attractive female, skilled and physically satisfying. Sublime would be all the above but also where there are emotions involved, the mood is correct and the love making is done slowly to draw out every ounce of satisfaction, both emotionally and physically, as possible. Arguably, that's where sublime pipe smoking is superior. When you're done with a sublime bowl of tobacco, you don't have to snuggle the pipe or wake up holding it the next morning. You dump the freaking ashes and move onto whatever you wish to do next.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: gamzultovah