I am still new to this whole endeavor as well, and I started off with all bents. Last month I was in a local B&M and they had a nice grained straight billiard basket pipe on clearance for $20 so I picked it up. It has easily become one of my favorites and it's nice and lightweight which is good since I am a clencher as well. I have to be able to move around when in my shop smoking, so unless I'm sitting on the porch reading with a glass of scotch, I have to have mobility. Pick up a cheap one you like the look of and see what happens. Worst case, you don't like it and then stop spending time thinking about it and can focus on what you do like. Cheers!