Spark Plug... Plume?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

JOHN72

Lifer
Sep 12, 2020
5,824
57,283
51
Spain - Europe
I made this gift to my colleague and friend Dan, with a lot of illusion. Sorry Dan. 🥲 The thing is that it smells great and only a few small bits of whitish powder. I think we will have to smoke this blend with absolute priority, before this tasty tobacco ends up in hell itself. It really pisses me off to save tobacco only to find shit later. I don't blame anyone, it's just the inevitable process of organic degradation. Maybe it's time to buy more whiskey, alcohol doesn't expire 🤦🥵.😬🧨🧨🧨
 

Masterblaster

Starting to Get Obsessed
Dec 23, 2021
161
623
45
Evans, GA
That powdery pattern in the top image looks like mold, and I'd toss it. Plume, which I've been given to understand is mineral residue that gradually transitions to the surface over time looks more like strata or veins in the tobacco. However, you describe the deposit as sparkling, which is more typical of plume than of mold. Then again, it's tinned by C&D, so mold is a higher probability.

I dunno, but I don't like the looks of it. Personally I'd toss it. When in doubt, throw it out.

But, they're your lungs to damage, not mine, so your choice.
I definitely do not have the years of experience that you do saddlebrush52! I was definitely concerned seeing as I've never experienced mold or Bloom yet, I really was hesitant to smoke this but also didn't want to waste the tobacco for no reason! So like I said earlier in the post I reached out to smoking pipes.com and C&D, they reassured me it was definitely not mold! Here's their responses for posterity sake!

SmokingPipes.com:
"In my experience this doesn't look like mold you would typically see on tobacco. Molded tobacco looks quite similar to moldy produce, with fuzzy, off white or greenish mold that spreads rapidly. The best course of action would be to place this in an empty mason jar and seal it up. When mold is exposed to fresh oxygen it will rapidly propagate. However, if there is no mold it will look and smell the same. I suggest isolating it for a week to see for sure. If mold blooms we can definitely help arrange for a reshipment of a new tin, or a refund!"

C&D Jeremy Reeves:
"Thank you for emailing us with your concern.This is definitely not mold. The dusting you see here is actually depositing of oils and sugars resulting from the pressing of the blend. Mold will be fuzzy and raised up from the surface of the tobacco, rather than being a crystalline or powdery appearance on the edges of individual pieces of leaf. This discoloration is actually a bi-product of fermentation and pressure, causing oils and sugars to be forced to the edges of the block.

Rest assured that what you have shown in these pictures is not mold, and the tobacco is untainted."

I also found an old ask G.L. Pease on the topic:
"First, it’s not clear those shiny jewels sometimes found on tobaccos are "sugar crystals," though they’re often referred to as such. Several times when I’ve discovered these glistening indicators of potential yumminess, I’ve done some rudimentary playing with them, though no full-scale analysis, and found them not sweet, not very soluble, and not very likely to be sugar. More likely, they are organic acids that have precipitated as a result of pH or other changes in the leaf’s chemistry as it ages. Nevertheless, the presence of these crystals usually indicates something good has happened to the tobacco that hosts them, and we’re generally rightfully excited to see them.

Mold, on the other hand, is rather different. How can you tell if it’s there? Your nose will offer the first clue. Moldy tobacco stinks in a way that is difficult to describe, but once you’ve smelled it, you’ll never forget it, and, most people wouldn’t even be tempted to smoke the stuff. Imagine the aroma of mildew combined with the ammoniac scent of soft, ripe cheeses well past their prime. If it was mold, I’m pretty sure you’d know it by nose alone."

I also found some pictures online of other tobacco plugs with small spots of mold on them and they looked nothing like what I had going on, especially after looking through the loop. I let the tobacco sit in a jar for 2 weeks with no indication of any mold growth or off putting smells! After a few bowls I decided I didn't want to deal with cutting on the plug every time I wanted to smoke it so I cut the whole thing up and rubbed it out and it probably took me two weeks to smoke through it and again no indication of mold. So I was pretty confident that it was some type of Bloom and definitely not mold, it was delicious and I had no ill effects!
Just opened a GLP Spark Plug tin from 2020 (which was kindly gifted by @JOHN72) with the same white substance on it. The tin was quite bulgy with a big hiss of air when I opened it. @JOHN72 had the same issue with other tins, I think this topic is quite a reassurance for the both of us this looks actually not as mold.

View attachment 180019
I can't be 100% sure about your tobacco DanWil84 as I can't see it in person! But from the pictures it looks exactly like what I had going on! I would smoke it in a heartbeat!puffy
 
Last edited:

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
20,707
48,992
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
I definitely do not have the years of experience that you do saddlebrush52! I was definitely concerned seeing as I've never experienced mold or Bloom yet, I really was hesitant to smoke this but also didn't want to waste the tobacco for no reason! So like I said earlier in the post I reached out to smoking pipes.com and C&D, they reassured me it was definitely not mold! Here's their responses for posterity sake!

SmokingPipes.com:
"In my experience this doesn't look like mold you would typically see on tobacco. Molded tobacco looks quite similar to moldy produce, with fuzzy, off white or greenish mold that spreads rapidly. The best course of action would be to place this in an empty mason jar and seal it up. When mold is exposed to fresh oxygen it will rapidly propagate. However, if there is no mold it will look and smell the same. I suggest isolating it for a week to see for sure. If mold blooms we can definitely help arrange for a reshipment of a new tin, or a refund!"

C&D Jeremy Reeves:
"Thank you for emailing us with your concern.This is definitely not mold. The dusting you see here is actually depositing of oils and sugars resulting from the pressing of the blend. Mold will be fuzzy and raised up from the surface of the tobacco, rather than being a crystalline or powdery appearance on the edges of individual pieces of leaf. This discoloration is actually a bi-product of fermentation and pressure, causing oils and sugars to be forced to the edges of the block.

Rest assured that what you have shown in these pictures is not mold, and the tobacco is untainted."

I also found an old ask G.L. Pease on the topic:
"First, it’s not clear those shiny jewels sometimes found on tobaccos are "sugar crystals," though they’re often referred to as such. Several times when I’ve discovered these glistening indicators of potential yumminess, I’ve done some rudimentary playing with them, though no full-scale analysis, and found them not sweet, not very soluble, and not very likely to be sugar. More likely, they are organic acids that have precipitated as a result of pH or other changes in the leaf’s chemistry as it ages. Nevertheless, the presence of these crystals usually indicates something good has happened to the tobacco that hosts them, and we’re generally rightfully excited to see them.

Mold, on the other hand, is rather different. How can you tell if it’s there? Your nose will offer the first clue. Moldy tobacco stinks in a way that is difficult to describe, but once you’ve smelled it, you’ll never forget it, and, most people wouldn’t even be tempted to smoke the stuff. Imagine the aroma of mildew combined with the ammoniac scent of soft, ripe cheeses well past their prime. If it was mold, I’m pretty sure you’d know it by nose alone."

I also found some pictures online of other tobacco plugs with small spots of mold on them and they looked nothing like what I had going on, especially after looking through the loop. I let the tobacco sit in a jar for 2 weeks with no indication of any mold growth or off putting smells! After a few bowls I decided I didn't want to deal with cutting on the plug every time I wanted to smoke it so I cut the whole thing up and rubbed it out and it probably took me two weeks to smoke through it and again no indication of mold. So I was pretty confident that it was some type of Bloom and definitely not mold, it was delicious and I had no ill effects!

I can't be 100% sure about your tobacco DanWil84 as I can't see it in person! But from the pictures it looks exactly like what I had going on! I would smoke it in a heartbeat!puffy
Save those emails! If they're wrong you can always sue them for the cost of the double lung transplant!


Just kidding.



Sorta...
 

drayve85

Starting to Get Obsessed
If you see fuzz, then it’s mold. Sparkly crystaly goodness, then it’s plume!
I just heard about "plume" in a recent thread but I do know my mold and this round spot in particular reminds me of what I've seen on my raw tobacco leaves many times before. Mold.

View attachment 173143

Besides that I can't make out any crystallization on any part of the pictures but I do see fuzz.
If you observe the same with your bare eyes up close, I'd say it's mold.