Soap Cellaring. A Som Besths Miracle!

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

jaytex1969

Lifer
Jun 6, 2017
9,651
52,020
Here
Note: "Som Besths" will mean nothing to the majority of members here. It means a lot to those who participated in last year's Secret Santa.

I recently came to the end of my 8 pack of Ivory soap, the only soap I've ever used in my 55 years of butt washing.

I went to the store and bought another, noting that the packaging was different. I proceeded to wash said butt.

Something was wrong. The smell (of the soap) was different. The lather different. After the shower, I felt encased in a residue and a mild burning of the skin came about.

I looked at the soap. It was definitely different, I was emotionally impacted and near shock.

What have they done?

I got online and soon learned that the greedy bastards at Proctor & Gamble had decided that wrecking a 105 year old formula was preferable to raising the cost by a nickle per bar to keep in line with current costs.

I contacted them, using the strongest language possible without scoring a restraining order. I received the expected generic corporate response.

I immediately placed an order for the "next best thing", some Dr Bronner's castile soap.

Then, I went on a rampage. It had been about 3 months since the changeover. There had to be some of the real deal still out there.

Up one side of the strip and down the other, hitting a dozen groceries, pharmacies and general stores.

Finally, at an Ingles grocery, one remaining 4 pack of the old formula. Sensing that their inventory system was different from other establishments, I focused my quest on other Ingles stores.

My third stop, heading into the sleepy suburb of north Knoxville, hit pay-dirt.

A canvass shopping bag jammed to the brim with old school Ivory soap. Over 160 bars for just under $120.

MAYBE enough to last me to my end of days and insulate me from this maddening world just a bit more.

Fuck you, Proctor & Gamble.



Forum Sig.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:

BingBong

Lifer
Apr 26, 2024
1,477
6,350
London UK
Yup, they can't help themselves but wreck a reliable product.

Wasn't Ivory the one that had a pic of a pretty woman on it who got removed, for being in some racy flick or something? Edit: ah no, that was Ivory Snow soap flakes and the model was Marylin Chambers. My front door is green. Might explain a lot...
 
Last edited:

Hillcrest

Lifer
Dec 3, 2021
3,794
19,273
Connecticut, USA
Dove Wintercare used to sell out quickly. It was a popular product. Solution ? Stop making it. Happens alot with many products. The prices on bar soap are outrageous now for some reason. I'm sorry to hear that about Ivory. Another sign of the impending apocalypse. You'll wash with nothing and be happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaytex1969
Aug 1, 2012
4,886
5,709
USA
Condolences for your loss. Seriously though, I only used ivory as a kid and young man. Switched because of my now ex-wife and still occasionally buy a few bars. I guess that's over...RIP.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaytex1969

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
12,912
21,600
SE PA USA
Unironically, making your own soap with combinations of lard, olive, almond, castor, shea and cocoa butters and essential oils like rosemary, lavender, mint and anything else you may want is dead easy, just takes time for it to cure. You can make phenomenally good soap.

My father was (among other things) a research chemist. He did some product testing over the years, and we often had cases of leftover stuff from his lab, including Ivory and Neutrogena soaps.

Actually, you can make better soap that Ivory, which, to my taste, is way too harsh. It doesn't have enough excess oils, and leaves my skin dry. Since I grew up with Ivory, I'm partial to it's aroma, but once I used Neutrogena, I never went back to Ivory. But Neutrogena is pretty pricey and a bar doesn't last very long.

So I've been making my own soap for a long time, and to do it right is not exactly simple. You need to measure and calculate the ratios of ingredients correctly (there are online spreadsheets for that), you need a high powered immersion blender, and you need soap molds. You need to be comfortable with handling sodium hydroxide (lye). Then the soap needs to cure, or more accurately, it needs to dry out. If you live in the desert, that's relatively easy. If you live anywhere with a Rh over 40%, not so easy. Some soapmakers resort to a sort of reverse humidor, a room or closet with a dehumidifier running all the time. Otherwise, you are likely to develop an orange mold on the soap. I add the same anti-fungal used in pipe tobacco to my soap, and that helps.

But yeah, once you use a good, well-made homemade soap, made with a healthy excess of oils, you won't go back to Ivory.