Seattle Pipe Club Potlatch, Discussion Not Review

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,211
60,627
Maybe two years ago, I bought a 2 oz tin of SP Potlatch, and later on an irresistible sale, another 8 oz tin, all without sampling it, which is not my usual deliberative thrifty habit. By the time I opened the two ounces recently, the lid had gotten a film of dust. Meantime, Potlatch has been under discussed and Plum Pudding the the Reserve version have gotten a lot of love. I have an unopened 2 oz regular tin of that, for later comparison. I opened Potlatch with skepticism, thinking it might be only so-so. Its seven ingredients listed on the tin are black Cavendish, burley, bright Virginias, Turkish Orientals, and Perique. I've had one bowl in a medium-size conical Dublin pipe and a second in a larger bowl (about Group 5) poker/pot hand carved in Mountain Laurel. Luckily, the blend is decidedly my style, as the burley might signal. The flavors are robust but not overbearing. The effect is complex but not intricate, fairly steady-on through the bowl with notes from each of the constituent tobaccos in a fulsome pleasing way. After only two bowls, I may comment further, but I feel quite satisfied having eight or ten ounces on hand, and that tells me that this is a right blend for me. And thanks to the member who expressed interest on the blend after hearing that I'd opened the tin.
 

jaytex1969

Lifer
Jun 6, 2017
9,643
51,982
Here
I smoked through an entire half pound tin of it and it was the first time I had ever really focused on a blend and got to know it really well.

There's a lot going on in there and it was your advice, MSO, that led me to break out a nice, wide chambered pipe to fully realize the blend's character.

I'd be interested to know if your experiences between the two different sized pipes was similar to mine and other people's.

I imagine the age you've accrued on your tin has probably tamed it a bit, as well. I may need to now pop an older one for comparison. Like you, however, I have numerous baggies and smaller quantities to go through and actually rarely pop a tin these days.

#firstworldproblems. :col:



13579
 

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,211
60,627
jay', I suspect the longer aging, relatively, after buying the tin probably did mellow and meld the numerous tobaccos. Yes, the smaller conical bowl gave me a slightly milder profile, and the bigger bowl opened it out and showed me a little more edge. If you like non-aromatic English blends with burley, and are an experienced smoker, this might be a good choice for you. I can see, for someone starting out, Potlatch could be a little much, especially without the additional aging. For me, it came across as distinctly friendly.
 

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,211
60,627
After several more bowls of Potlatch, I'm glad I opened my 2 oz tin and bought an 8 ounce tin for the future before I even sampled it. I think Plum Pudding and the Reserve version have thrown Potlatch in the shade, but it is engagingly complex with eight or so different tobaccos that actually come together well and harmonize like an professional orchestra. Burley is a definite but not overbearing part of the blend which makes it especially good to me. If you like English blends but also like burley, this is a good bet, though you might want to try a 2 ounce tin before you take the leap to 8. PC Midtown series Chestnut has a similarly high number of tobaccos and is also a good bet for burley smokers, but it doesn't have quite the level of refinement as Potlatch. Mighty good.
 

Sonorisis

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 24, 2019
855
4,587
I've smoked my way through a 2 oz. tin of Potlatch. As you've all said, it is complex, which makes it an entertaining smoke to me. I have a couple of tins on the back shelf. I'll get back to it when I work my way through the gazillion (many) working jars I've got going on these days. For some reason, it reminds me of Frog Morton Cellar. Not that it has the same flavor profile, but the array of tobaccos provides the same kind of diverse experience as FMC. At any rate, it is a good smoke -- perhaps the best SPC has to offer.
 

whitesands77

Starting to Get Obsessed
Oct 12, 2016
103
27
Denver USA
I prefer Potlatch to Plum Pudding or Mississippi River myself. I smoked through a tin and purchased a pound of it to cellar. It already has the body I like and is plenty complex for my taste. When I dont have Penzance it takes its place quite nicely.
 

wyfbane

Lifer
Apr 26, 2013
5,213
3,925
Tennessee
I was fortunate enough to be at a SPC event when they rolled out Potlatch. Potlatch it was a hit then and has continued to be a great smoke. It is complex, but doesn't overwhelm. The different parts all play nicely together. I have a fair amount of it. Good stuff! Thanks for the discussion, MSO!
 

logs

Lifer
Apr 28, 2019
1,876
5,084
What are your SPC favorites if I may ask?

I don't want to suggest I've dug deep into their catalog because I haven't, but I'm extremely fond of Mississippi River Special Reserve (which is not an English, I don't care what people say). Plum Pudding has a lot of merit too. I have to be in the right frame of mind to go in that direction but I can see what SPC is trying to do with it. Potlatch, on the other hand, feels directionless to me.
 

elasmo

Can't Leave
Mar 23, 2019
329
793
Stocked up on the Potlatch myself, cause P&C were basically giving it away a couple years ago. Very reminiscent of H&H Concerto....if I had to do a taste test, I wouldn't be able to tell them apart.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.