School me on Mylar

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

3 Fresh Yeti Pipes
11 Fresh Ropp Pipes
24 Fresh Rossi Pipes
18 Fresh Estate Pipes
18 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Winnipeger

Lifer
Sep 9, 2022
1,288
9,694
Winnipeg
Thanks @originalnutcracker! "Mylar" is a common word on the forums so not super easy to search out threads on the topic. I know it's been covered again and again, and it'll come up again and again. By the way, did you order the bags directly from Pleasant Grove Farms? As has been mentioned, amazon.ca kind of sucks and the seller information is not reliable. Also, f@ck Jeff Bezos. Did I say that already?
 

originalnutcracker

Can't Leave
Feb 26, 2018
304
2,023
63
Winnipeg, MB, Canada
Thanks @originalnutcracker! "Mylar" is a common word on the forums so not super easy to search out threads on the topic. I know it's been covered again and again, and it'll come up again and again. By the way, did you order the bags directly from Pleasant Grove Farms? As has been mentioned, amazon.ca kind of sucks and the seller information is not reliable. Also, f@ck Jeff Bezos. Did I say that already?
Direct from Pleasant Grove. It’s great stuff. I wary of Amazon, as they have a propensity to sell you cheap junk. It’s false economy to buy suspect quality.

Caution though - the shipping to Canada can be outrageous - so I make a point of bulk ordering. The first order I did was getting my feet wet, and smallish, and the shipping was more than the Mylar. I made sure the next order was worthwhile!

Then of course some Wally at customs thinks it’s super valuable something or other and dings you some more.....

Best to ship to Mike’s in Pembina if you can..... avoid a lot of expense if you’re going down anyway to Happy Harry’s to pick up the Everclear to clean your pipes!!!
 

chopper

Lifer
Aug 24, 2019
1,480
3,324
I'm not surprised. Amazon is a cesspool of misinformation and made up tripe from the various sellers on it. Wall thickness is wall thickness and a 7 layer laminate is .7 mill and that's the wall thickness. Screw Amazon's crappy standards and definitions.

But, you should know that the Earth is shaped like a cube.
A cube you say?
Shit, don't tell the Flat-Earthers or they'll really lose it.

z-evil laugh - austin powers alter ego.jpg
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
12,925
21,671
SE PA USA
Heat seal is a must for long-term storage. The zip seal is the weak link, especially after it’s been opened and closed a few times, and tobacco has become lodged in it.

As for vacuuming, I prefer it. It removes most of the air so that anaerobic aging can get a jump start. I also have tried nitrogen flushing, not sure if that is worth it. Time will tell!
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
21,020
50,375
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Heat seal is a must for long-term storage. The zip seal is the weak link, especially after it’s been opened and closed a few times, and tobacco has become lodged in it.

As for vacuuming, I prefer it. It removes most of the air so that anaerobic aging can get a jump start. I also have tried nitrogen flushing, not sure if that is worth it. Time will tell!
There's an interesting article on Greg Pease's site regarding vacuum sealing as a way to retard aging:
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoosierpipeguy

Winnipeger

Lifer
Sep 9, 2022
1,288
9,694
Winnipeg
There's an interesting article on Greg Pease's site regarding vacuum sealing as a way to retard aging:
This article raises more questions than it answers about aging tobacco in Mylar. How much H2O escapes from vacuum-sealed Mylar as opposed to vacuum-sealed plastic, versus glass jars? I don't think Mylar would present the same problem of moisture loss as the vacuum-sealed plastic in this article. YES the tobacco will age more if it has oxygen to react with. Maybe that's a bad thing if you want to leave your tobacco sitting for 40 years though. I'm 45 so, maybe vacuum sealing in Mylar with silica packs is a good bet for the deepest part of my cellar. If you can retard the aging process, only to resume it at some later date, that would be a good way to manage the cellar. Or would the 30 or 40 year old tobacco just turn to dust upon exposure to O2 and pathogens after sitting for so long?
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
21,020
50,375
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
This article raises more questions than it answers about aging tobacco in Mylar. How much H2O escapes from vacuum-sealed Mylar as opposed to vacuum-sealed plastic, versus glass jars? I don't think Mylar would present the same problem of moisture loss as the vacuum-sealed plastic in this article. YES the tobacco will age more if it has oxygen to react with. Maybe that's a bad thing if you want to leave your tobacco sitting for 40 years though. I'm 45 so, maybe vacuum sealing in Mylar with silica packs is a good bet for the deepest part of my cellar. If you can retard the aging process, only to resume it at some later date, that would be a good way to manage the cellar. Or would the 30 or 40 year old tobacco just turn to dust upon exposure to O2 and pathogens after sitting for so long?
.7mil metallized Mylar is impermeable, so zero H2O escapes.
As for the effect of opening a container of 60 year old "Whatsis", it may be fine for a few hours after exposure to fresh oxygen, might even last a day, but it will go tits up and die within s few days. So when you open that container of 60 year old "Whatsis" have a pile of smoking buddies around to smoke it up right away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Winnipeger
Jan 28, 2018
14,053
158,427
67
Sarasota, FL
I've read a lot on aging and there's different opinions as one might guess. I bet on leaving oxygen in the storage medium. I sold as much of what I stored in Mason jars as I could except for my faves. The jars just take up too much space. Probably 85% of what I now have is in tins. I'm 65 so I don't have to worry about 40 years. I heat sealed my mylar bags with a clothes iron.

Mylar nor mason jars are 100% impermiable. But close enough for the purpose of storing tobacco it doesn't matter. If I were starting from scratch, I'd go 100% with mylar bags. Mason jars are hard to stack and much heavier. And more expensive.
 
May 8, 2017
1,660
1,859
Sugar Grove, IL, USA
Heat seal is a must for long-term storage. The zip seal is the weak link, especially after it’s been opened and closed a few times, and tobacco has become lodged in it.

As for vacuuming, I prefer it. It removes most of the air so that anaerobic aging can get a jump start. I also have tried nitrogen flushing, not sure if that is worth it. Time will tell!
100% agree regarding the sealing. The zip seal is only adequate for short- to medium-term storage. Think months, not years.

Regarding vacuuming, I have found vacuum sealing ribbon tobacco in mylar effectively creates cake tobacco in my commercial chamber vacuum sealer. However, as long as the tobacco isn't significantly cased, it runs back out into ribbons with a bit of effort.
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
12,925
21,671
SE PA USA
100% agree regarding the sealing. The zip seal is only adequate for short- to medium-term storage. Think months, not years.

Regarding vacuuming, I have found vacuum sealing ribbon tobacco in mylar effectively creates cake tobacco in my commercial chamber vacuum sealer. However, as long as the tobacco isn't significantly cased, it runs back out into ribbons with a bit of effort.
My upright vacuum sealer has both timed and manual vacuum control, so I can squash it incredibly compact, or not at all. It will also do gas flush. It’s a PAC unit, bought it gov’t surplus years ago for $35. I was lucky!
 

Zeno Marx

Starting to Get Obsessed
Oct 10, 2022
277
1,405
My upright vacuum sealer has both timed and manual vacuum control, so I can squash it incredibly compact, or not at all. It will also do gas flush. It’s a PAC unit, bought it gov’t surplus years ago for $35. I was lucky!
What does PAC stand for? I'm curious about vacuum sealers as a means to prevent aging. I'm of the sort who prefers new tobacco to aged tobacco. This sounds like an exceptional unit, and I'd appreciate more information. Thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: woodsroad

glpease

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jun 17, 2010
239
96
California
A few notes. There are materials designed to be good water barriers, and materials that are good "gas" barriers, and, no, they're not the same. It has to do with polar (like water) vs. non-polar molecules. Plastic bags, no matter how thick, are not ideal for long term aging or storage. They'll keep the moisture in just fine, but other important things will dance right through them. That's why you can smell most tobaccos through plastic bags. As Sable pointed out, multi-layer metalized mylar is a good option, as they are made with separate high-barrier layers. Foil/mylar bags used for coffee, an industry that understands this technology well, are excellent.

Vacuum sealing is both unnecessary, and not ideal, as discussed in the article linked ^ up there. I've experimented with foil/mylar bags in the past, even using them for a time for my 8oz packaging, and they performed excellently, but, sadly, were not well received by either customers or retailers, who just didn't like the "unconventional" packaging despite its many advantages. (Lighter shipping weight being only one of them.)
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
12,925
21,671
SE PA USA
What does PAC stand for? I'm curious about vacuum sealers as a means to prevent aging. I'm of the sort who prefers new tobacco to aged tobacco. This sounds like an exceptional unit, and I'd appreciate more information. Thanks.
PAC makes commercial vacuum packaging machinery. I never would have bought it new, but it was up for auction with a $35 minimum bid, so I bit, and won. Had to drive up to Tobyhanna Army Depot to pick it up.
Here's my unit, more or less, without the digital display: PVG Industrial Vacuum Sealer - PAC Machinery - https://www.pacmachinery.com/products/pvg-vacuum-sealer/
I use it for everything from string beans and pork chops to ammunition, tobacco and packing for backpack trips.
 
Dec 3, 2021
5,569
48,407
Pennsylvania & New York
.7mil metallized Mylar is impermeable, so zero H2O escapes.
As for the effect of opening a container of 60 year old "Whatsis", it may be fine for a few hours after exposure to fresh oxygen, might even last a day, but it will go tits up and die within s few days. So when you open that container of 60 year old "Whatsis" have a pile of smoking buddies around to smoke it up right away.
It seems like the logical solution to long term Mylar storage would be to seal many chamber sized packets up—this way, in sixty years, you could just open a packet at a time and have your "fresh" sixty year old tobacco at hand, ready to smoke without worrying about it dying off like it might if it was all in one bag.
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
12,925
21,671
SE PA USA
Vacuum sealing is both unnecessary, and not ideal, as discussed in the article linked ^ up there. I've experimented with foil/mylar bags in the past, even using them for a time for my 8oz packaging, and they performed excellently, but, sadly, were not well received by either customers or retailers, who just didn't like the "unconventional" packaging despite its many advantages. (Lighter shipping weight being only one of them.)
Greg, the article on your site references the use of the Tilia Foodsaver system. The Foodsaver bags, unlike Mylar laminate bags, are not barrier bags. I see no reason why high-quality barrier bags would not perform on par with glass, at least for 10 years or so. I do not know how fast Mylar breaks down, nor have I done any literature searches on it, but metallized polyester is bound to deteriorate over time, subject to variables such as temperature and UV exposure.

As for acceptance of barrier bags by retailers and customers, the tobacco business is stubborn slow to change steeped in tradition. Esoterica has managed to make it happen, though. Maybe if you you moved your operations to remote island in the Atlantic Ocean and cut production by 2/3'ds, customers would be more accepting of Mylar bags!
 

glpease

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jun 17, 2010
239
96
California
Greg, the article on your site references the use of the Tilia Foodsaver system. The Foodsaver bags, unlike Mylar laminate bags, are not barrier bags. I see no reason why high-quality barrier bags would not perform on par with glass, at least for 10 years or so. I do not know how fast Mylar breaks down, nor have I done any literature searches on it, but metallized polyester is bound to deteriorate over time, subject to variables such as temperature and UV exposure.

As for acceptance of barrier bags by retailers and customers, the tobacco business is stubborn slow to change steeped in tradition. Esoterica has managed to make it happen, though. Maybe if you you moved your operations to remote island in the Atlantic Ocean and cut production by 2/3'ds, customers would be more accepting of Mylar bags!
That article came from a friend of mine, who did his own experiments. There are foodsaver bags that are higher-barrier than the standard ones, but even then, they won't perform as well as multi-layer foil/Mylar bags. Basically, if you can see light through it, it's probably not ideal.

Mylar (did you know there are over 300 types?), like all PETs, can break down over time if exposed to UV, so it's advisable to store them for long term use in the dark. But, the bags I experimented with have shown no degradation over nearly 20 years. One thing I really liked about them is that the open tops could be folded over several times and secured with a binder clip, forming an excellent seal. I've had tobacco in one since my early exploration of them, tasting it periodically, and it's still in perfect condition, though the repeated exposure to the atmosphere have prevented real aging from happening. Indeed, a good high-barrier bag is a great alternative to glass. Most are internally coated with a copolymer that allows for heat sealing. They're light, don't break, and have the added benefit of being able to adapt to content quantity. I think they're great.

I'll see about building a tobacco factory "on" the Principality of Sealand (look it up - it's a hoot). That would definitely add a bit to the "exotic" factor, although transportation costs resulting from the 7mile dinghy trips back and fort might prove to be prohibitive... That is, if they let me on the "island" to begin with. ;)
 
Dec 3, 2021
5,569
48,407
Pennsylvania & New York
That article came from a friend of mine, who did his own experiments. There are foodsaver bags that are higher-barrier than the standard ones, but even then, they won't perform as well as multi-layer foil/Mylar bags. Basically, if you can see light through it, it's probably not ideal.

Mylar (did you know there are over 300 types?), like all PETs, can break down over time if exposed to UV, so it's advisable to store them for long term use in the dark. But, the bags I experimented with have shown no degradation over nearly 20 years. One thing I really liked about them is that the open tops could be folded over several times and secured with a binder clip, forming an excellent seal. I've had tobacco in one since my early exploration of them, tasting it periodically, and it's still in perfect condition, though the repeated exposure to the atmosphere have prevented real aging from happening. Indeed, a good high-barrier bag is a great alternative to glass. Most are internally coated with a copolymer that allows for heat sealing. They're light, don't break, and have the added benefit of being able to adapt to content quantity. I think they're great.

I'll see about building a tobacco factory "on" the Principality of Sealand (look it up - it's a hoot). That would definitely add a bit to the "exotic" factor, although transportation costs resulting from the 7mile dinghy trips back and fort might prove to be prohibitive... That is, if they let me on the "island" to begin with. ;)

Maybe some of us will become Lords or Dukes soon. Hmmm.

 

Puffaluffaguss

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 30, 2021
702
2,230
33
The City Different