Recommend a quality good 1st aromatic please!

[downr4nge]

<p>@beastinview, the blood red moon and autumn evening get delivered today so I still like aros!

 

[Chasing Embers]

Just got some Autumn Evening in the mail today too, and am smoking a bowl in an MM Mark Twain. You 're in for a treat!

 

[downr4nge]

I'm this close to pulling the trigger on some Frog Morton's on the Bayou, Mississippi River, and another aro.

 

[downr4nge]

Just ordered some Frog Morton's on the Bayou, Mississippi River, and Trout Stream.
I received my tin of Cult Blood Red Moon and Cornell & Diehl Autumn Evening. Both smell amazing! The C&D smells like butterscotch and pancakes. The Cult smells like a Tootsie cherry lollipop. I only had a few puffs of the Cult and my goodness, it is good stuff! Thanks all for recommending it!

 

[beastinview]

Glad to hear you're enjoying it! I'm a bit like you: my tastes run the gamut.

 

[ltstone]

DownR4ange: Let us know what you think of Autumn Evening. Like many others here I also have been smoking it alot lately especially now my tongue is tougher and can finally handle those sugary red virginias.

 

[davet]

Captain Black Red Sky, another cherry flavour & my favorite aromatic.

 

[downr4nge]

@ltstone, I smoked a bowl of the autumn evening today. I love the stuff. So far no tongue bite at all. Plus my colleagues love the room note.

 

[dochudson]

Thomas Radford's Sunday's Fantasy.

You can like it or not, but just open the envelope and sniff: it is worth the money.
Forgot about this.. it's very tasty.

 

[lincolnsbark]

My recommendations are Cult Conspiracy and Bald Headed Teacher from 4 noggins.

 

[tennsmoker]

Boswell's aros are top notch. Also Pipe Works & Wilke have some spectacular aros. 4Noggins is another good 'un for aros.
When I first began smoking a pipe, back in the 1960s! I smoked a lot of Green Sail (ugh, what was I thinking?) I soon switched over to some of Edward's Pipe Shop aros. Too much tongue bite.
I got into Vas and burleys pretty soon thereafter and have been in that realm mostly since. I love VaPers and VaBurs, and I gotta say that Frog Morton's Cellar is astoundingly good.
There are some great choices here for the novice and veteran alike.
Smoke on!

 

[downr4nge]

This Mississippi River and Frog Morton on the Bayou..... My goodness... I guess my story mirrors most here. Start out with aromatics, and move on to non-aros. So I get my order of MR, FM OTB, and Trout Stream today (which is wonderful as well). First thing I do is pop the tins and bag of Trout Stream. The tin notes of the MR and FM are soooo good...
Upon first picking up the hobby, I never knew there was a difference between aro and non-aro. I thought all pipe tobacco was cherry flavored. As you can see, I asked about aromatics here and purchased some amazing aros based on your recommendations. I happened across MM965 and took such a liking to it that I noticed I wanted to smoke that more than the aros. Who knew I'd like English blends above aros? Wow. Now, I'm getting ready to pack a bowl of this MR... Will report back on what I think.

 

[Chasing Embers]

Two words, Black Frigate. :mrgreen:

 

[davet]

Two words, Black Frigate.

Didn't see that one comin :rofl:

 

[iamn8]

I dream of a day when Frigate will be seen not for its color, but by the content of its character.

 

[okiebrad]

My wife loves the smell of trout stream. Satisfying personal flavor preference, I lean towards Sillem's Black or Frog Morton Cellar.