I saw that the "doctors'" knife was recommended earlier. That is what I use. I have an old Hen and Rooster from before the name was sold to "Frost Cutlery" ( the cable guy) that I got from A.G. Russell of Arkansas in the early 70's and I recently got another pricey one, a Case XX dressed up with Texas related impressed bolsters. I have the $9 one mentioned and agree that the way the blades are sloppily inset, it is too big for tamping all but very large pipes and, maybe the "pot" standard shape. The Case XX ( just under $100) is compact when folded, has the spatula, a small blade and a tamper shaped end, stag scales. It is not as well made as the H & R of old because the tamper/pill smasher uses the liners as part of the face, where a good vintage has a bolster that is flat but does cover the innards. I have a lot of knives and a fair number of premium, true customs in fixed and folding. My paternal grandfather, my father and I all collected pipes, and by 1994, together, we had nearly 2500, none of which were "drugstore." I sold down to now around 50-60 and through good fortune, they are mostly Dunhills, Charatans, and for years, Barlings were a family favorite. I am very fortunate, I know. Dad liked freehands too, while, Grandpa and I preferred standards and usually oversized. The truly vintage Barlings are superb. My Dad bought a new one the day I was born (1946) and when I was 21, he gave it to me- a beautiful OL Barling Billiard and I still have it.