I've seen both Pipers and Pipemen used to refer to pipe smokers, are their others? Which one is most commonly used and which do you prefer?
Inquiring minds want to know... ::
I know neither of which is more common, nor do I much have a preference. However, I do use "Piper" most often. On occasion I'll use "piping Lady," so perhaps this is an "other."
I can't stand either term. "Pipers" play music. "Pipe men" just sounds archaic.
I prefer "pipesmokers," one word, even though the spell-check here doesn't like it. It's clear, it can't be taken to refer to anything else, and it's gender-neutral.
True, "pipe smoker" is the only grammatically and historically correct usage, yet in personal experience I hear the frequent use of "piper and piping" more as a nickname. As a new pipe smoker, before I even heard anyone else use "piper," I just automatically used it because it was easy to type and I just liked the way it sounds!
Regarding gender neutrality, I've obviously missed that boat:
"A pipe in the mouth makes it clear that there has been no mistake – you are undoubtedly a man." - A. A. Milne
I say pipe smoker, plain and simple.
Piper is common around these parts but I dislike it and refrain from using it.
Pipemen is something I would never use, not because it isn't gender neutral (I loathe saying anything but fisherman or journeyman, etc) but because it is antiquated and strange to to the ear.
How many time has one heard over the yrs, "Oh yea, I know who you mean, he is a smoker isn't he?"(for cig smokers)
For pipe smokers, I have heard, yrs ago, "Oh yes, I know who you mean now, he's a pipeman isn't he"?
I am a PIPE SMOKER, or a lover of pipe tobacco. I am not a "piper", I don't know how to play the bagpipes (sadly), and I do not capture rats or steal children by playing my magic pipe-flute-thing. :P
A Pipe Man is "okay", because I'm neither politically correct or the slightest bit concerned with "gender neutrality". Hey, at least I'm honest.
I'm a pipesmoker. A piper plays the bagpipes. Pipemen is clunky,not to mention the fact that it leaves out the women who smoke, as does "Brethren of the Briar", which is also too darned long.