Seems that you may have mixed it a bit too wet. I woyld use saliva next time. I have read that it works better than watet. I'm going to go with fire place mortar as embers suggested earlier in the post.I tried pipe mudding some cobs for the first time. I used cigar ash and water. Mixed it to the consistency you want from what I’ve read. Let it sit for 3 days. It doesn’t seem that solid? Did I miss something? Do I try and take out the mixture or just smoke it?
i tried to get a pic but couldn’t get a good one. It shows that you can move the mud around.
View attachment 48373