Yep. I went from 1 pipe to 3 pipes to a spreadsheet as well. I can't tell how many I'd NEVER get rid of, so let's see.
<- This Peterson 314 was my first and only pipe for years and years when I only knew about BCA and 1Q. I'll die with it.
Both of my Savinelli 673's are special. I bought a set of matching Saint Nicholas's for all my pipe-smoking college friends at a bachelor party. I bought a pair of sandblasted Luisa Fiammatas for me and my brother, and that was his first pipe. So there's 3.
I've got a Peterson Sherlock and Mycroft from their Sherlock Holmes series. They're smooth-finished from a couple of years ago. The Mycroft was a consolation prize because the Sherlock was too expensive at the time, but then I turned around and bought the Sherlock anyway. Such is PAD. And as it turns out, the Mycroft smokes better. Now we're at 4 or 5.
My first really expensive pipe was my Vauen Auenland Almar because I wanted to channel Gandalf. I broke that pipe in at my grandfather's house and always think about him when I smoke it. So now it's 5 or 6.
I have a virgin Ser Jacopo Delecta L1 C that I'm going to break in on my 40th birthday here in a couple of months. The chamber isn't quite as big as
@Chasing Embers meer, but it's double the chamber of most of my pipes and half-again as big as my "enormous" Sherlock. Let's call it 7.
So, I would have trouble getting rid of half of my pipes. Here's a family photo from earlier this year when I thought I had a lot.
View attachment 233135