I can attest to your dirty little secret. I am now working on my 40+ year old pipes, (that I haven't smoked in 30 years) that sit in the corner of my study. They get a full dose of morning sun everyday and they are very badly oxidized and taste horrible. For the bits, I am using Oxy-Clean soak, Baking Soda/Hydrogen Peroxide paste, and 70% Iso Alcohol swab. Progress is very slow, but I'm getting there and looking forward to enjoying some new tobaccos I just acquired. These pipes may never see the sun again...You are going to get everyone's favorite way to get rid of the tarnish and I won't add to it. Basically, you have to remove it physically using whatever methods you prefer.
I'm posting because of a dirty little secret that no-one ever seems to talk about. Vulcanite tarnishes when exposed to light. The lower the quality, the quicker it tarnishes. High grade vulcanite like those on older Kaywoodies and Barlings and on big bucks Danish and American masters, etc., stay black and shiny, if you keep them in drawers, in the dark. Vulcanite is a bit like silver. Unless you keep them away from light, even on the most expensive pipes, they will tarnish. It's a decrepit material, whose intrinsic flaws are accepted only by old men with a tolerance for decrepitness.
.