Overthinking can also wreck a good smoke.
If I just want an easy reliable uncomplicated smoke, I go with burley in a cob. That’s probably half of my smokes.
I think it’s pretty undeniable that some smokes are just better than others, even with the same pipe and same tobacco. I think we can also account for most of these variables, figure them out, and repeat those perfect smokes more often than not. If getting there takes some effort and attention to detail, then that effort is well worth it. Hell, it’s not a whole lot more effort than just having a smoke in the first place, and once the pipe is lit, you can just enjoy it all the same.