Cosmic, I think those paddle shifters and other variations on automatic trans that offer a semi-shift option are just placating the consciences of people who think they'd rather drive manual but don't. I think the manual use on those approaches zero. I owned one of those and never used it, just because it came with a car I liked otherwise; I certainly didn't buy it for that. P.S. It was the best car I've owned in terms of amenities, but the warranty work was incredible -- two a.c. jobs, two engine fans, and a blown wheel bearing. It was a Subaru assembled in the U.S. I'd never had a car that needed that much work, but the service manager was a champ and took good care of me, and we got the car to where it should be. It was a life lesson in the fact that I don't need or want many bells and whistles.