is this original?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Ahi Ka

Lurker
Feb 25, 2020
6,717
32,134
Aotearoa (New Zealand)
Nothing wrong with Captain Black. It is a legitimate tobacco and it is one that is affordable for most people. It is a popular choice for many many smokers. Enjoy And welcome to the world of pipe smoking.
Hey hey, please don’t let logic and good sense get in the way of banter.

And yes welcome.

On a side note, on one the best aromatic smokes I’ve had was from a dried out decade old pouch of CB cherry.
 
it is one that is affordable for most people.
I was checking the prices on the OTC tobaccos at the drug store the other day, and Captain Black in the pouch was going for $12, meanwhile most cigarette brands can still be gotten for under $5 a pack. Seemed a little excessive to me.
My biggest problem with Captain Black was the humectant in it. It always seemed to leave my mouth dry and sore feeling... but the flavor is good, maybe a little monochromatic though.
 

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
I was checking the prices on the OTC tobaccos at the drug store the other day, and Captain Black in the pouch was going for $12, meanwhile most cigarette brands can still be gotten for under $5 a pack. Seemed a little excessive to me.
My biggest problem with Captain Black was the humectant in it. It always seemed to leave my mouth dry and sore feeling... but the flavor is good, maybe a little monochromatic though.
When I think about our OP, someone who represents economically many of the mass of people whom make Turkey their home, access to any tobacco at an affordable price is a challenge, especially for a young man. This is a smoker who has started his journey with a Chinese pipe made of acrylic, moved onto a pipe made of Walnut that is charring, and had no idea that meerschaum pipes were anything but tourist attractions.

I think for many on this forum, the realities of most people are so far removed that it is difficult to imagine how an older pouch of Captain Black Cherry is magic. And yet, for many it is.

When I was a broke college student, Lane 1Q was sheer magnificence. My own blend that I smoke has a lot of BCA in it. It isn't that I just love Lane BCA so much that I must use it as a mixer in my own blend, but it brings back memories of having a few smokes with friends between classes, working, and realizing that there was not time for much else.

What a kick it would be to send the OP a simple well made briar pipe with some good Virginia tobacco or a nice mild English blend. It would be like the heavens opened up and reigned down Tupelo honey on fresh from the oven plate of biscuits.
 
When I think about our OP, someone who represents economically many of the mass of people whom make Turkey their home, access to any tobacco at an affordable price is a challenge, especially for a young man. This is a smoker who has started his journey with a Chinese pipe made of acrylic, moved onto a pipe made of Walnut that is charring, and had no idea that meerschaum pipes were anything but tourist attractions.

I think for many on this forum, the realities of most people are so far removed that it is difficult to imagine how an older pouch of Captain Black Cherry is magic. And yet, for many it is.

When I was a broke college student, Lane 1Q was sheer magnificence. My own blend that I smoke has a lot of BCA in it. It isn't that I just love Lane BCA so much that I must use it as a mixer in my own blend, but it brings back memories of having a few smokes with friends between classes, working, and realizing that there was not time for much else.

What a kick it would be to send the OP a simple well made briar pipe with some good Virginia tobacco or a nice mild English blend. It would be like the heavens opened up and reigned down Tupelo honey on fresh from the oven plate of biscuits.
Weren't you like an English teacher or something? I swear, I think quite frequently that you and Briar Lee are the same person, because this long winded responses, while not as folksy or trite, still seems to ramble and ramble after you posted that you were replying to me, but in which you say nothing in actual response to my post.
I made no comment, nor do I have any idea, what someone in Turkey may have to pay for tobaccos. I merely replied to your post concerning this tobacco being "affordable to most," and I was merely saying that for most, it is rather expensive compared to other tobaccos at the same quantity in which this one is sold.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: anotherbob

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
I was checking the prices on the OTC tobaccos at the drug store the other day, and Captain Black in the pouch was going for $12, meanwhile most cigarette brands can still be gotten for under $5 a pack. Seemed a little excessive to me.
My biggest problem with Captain Black was the humectant in it. It always seemed to leave my mouth dry and sore feeling... but the flavor is good, maybe a little monochromatic though.
When I think about our OP, someone who represents economically many of the mass of people whom make Turkey their home, access to any tobacco at an affordable price is a challenge, especially for a young man. This is a smoker who has started his journey with a Chinese pipe made of acrylic, moved onto a pipe made of Walnut that is charring, and had no idea that meerschaum pipes were anything but tourist attractions.

I think for many on this forum, the realities of most people are so far removed that it is difficult to imagine how an older pouch of Captain Black Cherry is magic. And yet, for many it is.

When I was a broke college student, Lane 1Q was sheer magnificence. My own blend that I smoke has a lot of BCA in it. It isn't that I just love Lane BCA so much that I must use it as a mixer in my own blend, but it brings back memories of having a few smokes with friends between classes, working, and realizing that there was not time for much else.

What a kick it would be to send the OP a simple well made briar pipe with some good Virginia tobacco or a nice mild English blend. It would be like the heavens opened up and reigned down Tupelo honey on fresh from the oven plate of biscuits.
Weren't you like an English teacher or something? I swear, I think quite frequently that you and Briar Lee are the same person, because this long winded responses, while not as folksy or trite, still seems to ramble and ramble after you posted that you were replying to me, but in which you say nothing in actual response to my post.
I made no comment, nor do I have any idea, what someone in Turkey may have to pay for tobaccos. I merely replied to your post concerning this tobacco being "affordable to most," and I was merely saying that for most, it is rather expensive compared to other tobaccos at the same quantity in which this one is sold.
LOL. The problem with replies are that they really aren’t necessarily about a reply to the individual as much as they are a starting point for something else. Not always the case, but if Ty it is. As we discussed a while back, the reply button can be misleading in the intent. As an example, your reply to me has nothing to do with biscuits. And yet you still replied, LOL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Papamique

rossama

Lurker
Dec 2, 2022
24
13
Captain Black seems ok but Amphora which is also available in your country I believe is much better rated.
i looked like 6-8 shops and i find just captain black.
It also doesn't sound like tobacco is "illegal".
if tobacco is not certificated by government, that tobacco is illegal to sell.
Why in the world would anyone try to sell counterfeit Captain Black?
Right? but this is true.
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,660
31,230
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
It could just be contraband illegal tobacco, or maybe the place (if legit) paid fees to sell it. Or, maybe it is fake. But, it sounds like you took a big risk buying it. Captain Black is sort of famous for being goopy stick wet tobacco that is hard to dry. But, it is possible it had been setting on the shelf for years and years.
If you like it, smoke it. But, I would hazard to break the law with jail time attached to the risk. I've heard about Turkish prisons.
The movie Midnight Express left an impression.
Which the author of the book has stated that he actually didn't have a horrible time in Turkish prison but the publishers insisted he spice it up a lot.
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,660
31,230
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
Weren't you like an English teacher or something? I swear, I think quite frequently that you and Briar Lee are the same person, because this long winded responses, while not as folksy or trite, still seems to ramble and ramble after you posted that you were replying to me, but in which you say nothing in actual response to my post.
I made no comment, nor do I have any idea, what someone in Turkey may have to pay for tobaccos. I merely replied to your post concerning this tobacco being "affordable to most," and I was merely saying that for most, it is rather expensive compared to other tobaccos at the same quantity in which this one is sold.
they're twins and they're both finding out right now that they're both adopted.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ThermionicScott

rossama

Lurker
Dec 2, 2022
24
13
About the "fake" fact:
Here shops mix good tobacco and bad tobbaco and they fill to filtered tubes, they sell it.