Interesting Completed Ebay Auctions - British Pipes

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

New Cigars




PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

ssjones

Moderator
Staff member
May 11, 2011
18,317
11,070
Maryland
postimg.cc
This cross-cut is stunning.
I went to eBay, checked the original listing and it looks just as good on the other side. There’s much I’ve likely missed but I don’t remember seeing better birdseye on a British made pipe recently.
As sable said, if birdseye is your thing then it’s not going to get much better in British wood.
You are right, but I've just never seen that kind of price on almost any Peterson.

My XL90 Supreme only has that kind of birdseye on one side. No gold band, but 1/3 the cost (unsmoked, from Mark Irwin's book, he keeps asking if I want to sell it back to him - no!).
 

Attachments

  • Peterson_XL90_Supreme_1998_Gallery.JPG
    Peterson_XL90_Supreme_1998_Gallery.JPG
    67.3 KB · Views: 16

ssjones

Moderator
Staff member
May 11, 2011
18,317
11,070
Maryland
postimg.cc
And a B5 Gold Band Supreme (unsmoked, found at Boswells). It was $150, but only grain, no birdseye.
 

Attachments

  • Peterson_B5_Supreme_1998_Gallery.JPG
    Peterson_B5_Supreme_1998_Gallery.JPG
    62.4 KB · Views: 9

americaman

Part of the Furniture Now
May 1, 2019
943
3,098
Los Angeles, CA
You are right, but I've just never seen that kind of price on almost any Peterson.

My XL90 Supreme only has that kind of birdseye on one side. No gold band, but 1/3 the cost (unsmoked, from Mark Irwin's book, he keeps asking if I want to sell it back to him - no!).

George was telling me about Supremes with a gold band. What’s the draw to them? Rarity?
 

ssjones

Moderator
Staff member
May 11, 2011
18,317
11,070
Maryland
postimg.cc
George was telling me about Supremes with a gold band. What’s the draw to them? Rarity?
I guess. Not my cup of tea or preference. The good news is they are always very narrow, so not too over the top. The Supreme grade and grain attracted me to mine, not the band. (very tricky to read the hallmark, its so small)
 

irishearl

Lifer
Aug 2, 2016
2,146
3,762
Kansas
I guess. Not my cup of tea or preference. The good news is they are always very narrow, so not too over the top. The Supreme grade and grain attracted me to mine, not the band. (very tricky to read the hallmark, its so small)
I, too, have not been particularly attracted to gold bands. Silver, though, is another matter.
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
19,623
44,833
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
You are right, but I've just never seen that kind of price on almost any Peterson.

My XL90 Supreme only has that kind of birdseye on one side. No gold band, but 1/3 the cost (unsmoked, from Mark Irwin's book, he keeps asking if I want to sell it back to him - no!).
Hi Al,

That's an argument based on the value of the brand rather than the quality of the wood, which is how most of us base our buying decisions. I suspect that this is different because of the extremely high quality of the birdseye figure and not a reflection on Peterson values overall.
You watch enough of these auctions and you see outliers frequently and with every maker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpmcwjr

Kottan

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 5, 2020
508
1,329
Frankfurt am Main, Germany
You are right, but I've just never seen that kind of price on almost any Peterson.

My XL90 Supreme only has that kind of birdseye on one side. No gold band, but 1/3 the cost (unsmoked, from Mark Irwin's book, he keeps asking if I want to sell it back to him - no!).
Sometimes even lower graded pipes have amazing birdseye.
Last year I won this Charatan Dublin Bevedere ($139).
Charatan Belvedere Dublin 391Reuben Era.jpg
 

Kottan

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 5, 2020
508
1,329
Frankfurt am Main, Germany
That's some serious birdseye! Makes one wonder about various grading systems. that this gets a lower grading is based on what?
i've seen no flaws or sandpits on this pipe and have no idea how Charatan did their grading. In the 1951 Catalogue Crossgrain/birdseye is assigned to the Special grade. I have the impression that Charatan mainly focused on straight grain (and birdseye on the rim). We should ask Ken Barnes about the grading system.... Rarity, Belvedere, Perfection, Special, Distinction, Distinction Deluxe, After Hours, Executive, Executive Extra Large, Selected, Selected Extra Large, Supreme, Supreme S, Supreme 100, Supreme 150, Supreme 200, Supreme 250, Supreme 300, Coronation, Royal Achievement, Crown Achievement, Summa Cum Laude.... not to forget the sandblasts, freehands (FH) and the size groups (1 - 4) whereby the grading becomes still more complicated. E.g. a Belvedere group 4 is higher graded than a Special group1. Obviously dosn't the grain pattern matter that much in this case.
How can a human beeing differentiate all this?
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
19,623
44,833
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
i've seen no flaws or sandpits on this pipe and have no idea how Charatan did their grading. In the 1951 Catalogue Crossgrain/birdseye is assigned to the Special grade. I have the impression that Charatan mainly focused on straight grain (and birdseye on the rim). We should ask Ken Barnes about the grading system.... Rarity, Belvedere, Perfection, Special, Distinction, Distinction Deluxe, After Hours, Executive, Executive Extra Large, Selected, Selected Extra Large, Supreme, Supreme S, Supreme 100, Supreme 150, Supreme 200, Supreme 250, Supreme 300, Coronation, Royal Achievement, Crown Achievement, Summa Cum Laude.... not to forget the sandblasts, freehands (FH) and the size groups (1 - 4) whereby the grading becomes still more complicated. E.g. a Belvedere group 4 is higher graded than a Special group1. Obviously dosn't the grain pattern matter that much in this case.
How can a human beeing differentiate all this?
Human beings can't differentiate between all of that. It's marketing run wild.
 

peregrinus

Lifer
Aug 4, 2019
1,205
3,787
Pacific Northwest
How can a human beeing differentiate all this?
Perhaps there is no real explicit hierarchical sense because it is several generations of differing marketing strategy overlaid historically.
The originators never considered that someday someone would try to sort out equivalent rankings of differing terminology spread over decades. I imagine that, in particular, later management was likely just interested in stimulating sales.
It's marketing run wild.
Just as in nature, things tend to run wild in significant shifts. Leaving paleontologists and pipe collectors scratching their heads at what has been wrought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpmcwjr

Kottan

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 5, 2020
508
1,329
Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Perhaps there is no real explicit hierarchical sense because it is several generations of differing marketing strategy overlaid historically.
The originators never considered that someday someone would try to sort out equivalent rankings of differing terminology spread over decades. I imagine that, in particular, later management was likely just interested in stimulating sales.

Just as in nature, things tend to run wild in significant shifts. Leaving paleontologists and pipe collectors scratching their heads at what has been wrought.
Surly the numerous grades were invented and introduced by Herman Lane for a better and expanded marketing of the Charatan brand. Before he entered the scene Charatan had only a few quality grades i.e. De Luxe Sandblast, De Luxe, Special, Selected, Supreme. (1951).
But nevertheless the Grades which came tnereafter were
all placed in hierachical order. (the De Luxe grade was replaced by the Belvedere grade.) Here is a website with a Charatan retail price list, where you can find all the grades from 1970.

Estervals Pipe House - https://www.tecon-gmbh.de/info_pages.php?pages_id=121

Btw. the Supreme 100 came first up in 1958 as Jguss mentioned before in another thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmcmtk

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
5,491
13,920
Yeah, the whole Charatan "blizzard of grades" thing was Herman's doing, according to Basil Sullivan, anyway. (What John Loring was to Dunhill, Basil was to Charatan).

The sad bit, if you don't care for elaborate/ostentatious grading schemes, anyway, is that it isn't the makers pushing them on the public, but that buyers demand them. I've known any number of carvers who started out intending to follow the "my name and date and nothing else" nomenclature route, but gave in after a while rather than piss everyone off in addition to losing money.

The same brain thing that makes some people collectors in the first place will not rest until all that can be categorized has been categorized; and those who are concerned with the social status that that owning luxury goods confers like heirarchies as a way to keep score. i.e. "Mine cost more than yours."
 
  • Like
Reactions: jpmcwjr
May 8, 2017
1,593
1,627
Sugar Grove, IL, USA
Charatan was notoriously inconsistent in their grading. I listened to this exact discussion between Fred Hanna and Rich Esserman yesterday regarding the Achievement grade presently for sale at smokingpipes.com. They felt it was worthy of the grade, by the way. There was the mention of the "three pint Achievement." Humans are inconsistent. Some more than others.