I could see the shop owner cringe when I was a brand new pipe smoker, spent a while looking at his pipes and then said I wanted to try out some aromatics, but he quickly saved face. He was a kind soul and tried to sell me his cheap store blends (probabley laughing inside knowing how bad they were), however he also showed me his favorite English tobacco as well, which I also purchased. I ended up throwing everything away (all four aromatics) except for that wonderful Scotland Yard he gave me. Since then I have moved on to better tobaccos and rediscovered aromatics with Boswells (yes, aromatics I don't have to throw away). I thought it was a funny story, it's not a knock vs any kind (except mabey those super cheap store blend aromatics). They smell wonderful and taste like rancid rice.