If You Could Only Smoke One Tobacco For The Rest of Your Life...

[Wellington]

This will be tough to answer for a lot of you, i suppose threads like this probably pop up frequently. Humor me.
If you only could smoke one tobacco blend for the rest of your life, what would you choose?

Myself I'm so torn between Frog Morton Cellar and the simple Half & Half, but as much as I LOVED FMC, sometimes I just want something simple, so as crazy as it is I might just have to say H&H, but im also on a H&H kick at the moment so that might be swaying my decision haha

 

[ashdigger]

My cellar is wide and deep, but GRANGER is the one I keep reaching for. I absolutely mix it up, but I always return to Granger.

 

[ray47]

There has been many threads like this over time and my answer has always been Cornell & Diehl Pegasus and that hasn't changed.

 

[Richmond B. Funkenhouser]

Prince Albert

 

[Wellington]

My cellar is wide and deep, but GRANGER is the one I keep reaching for. I absolutely mix it up, but I always return to Granger.

I find Prince Albert and Carter Hall very similar to my palate, and the tin note is very similar. Half & Half has a noticeable difference in tin note and taste to me. I've never tried Granger though, out of the the otc I just listed, does Granger fit close to any of those?

 

[Richmond B. Funkenhouser]

I find Prince Albert and Carter Hall very similar to my palate, and the tin note is very similar. Half & Half has a noticeable difference in tin note and taste to me. I've never tried Granger though, out of the the otc I just listed, does Granger fit close to any of those?

I'd say Granger has it's on thing going.. it's closer to H&H, than it is to PA or CH.

 

[ashdigger]

I find Prince Albert and Carter Hall very similar to my palate, and the tin note is very similar. Half & Half has a noticeable difference in tin note and taste to me. I've never tried Granger though, out of the the otc I just listed, does Granger fit close to any of those?

To me, Velvet is the closest

 

[Jwebb90]

McClelland Pebblecut

 

[Perique]

Such a hard question to answer. I would probably have to say Escudo or maybe aged LNF. There are a number of blends I prefer, but they’re not all day blends for me. So it’s an interesting question that’s distinct from “What’s your favorite blend?”

Regardless of my choice, I think I would get bored smoking the same blend always.

 

[Richmond B. Funkenhouser]

I sure hope it doesnt come down to all Prince Albert, all of the time.

 

[jon11]

Hamborger Veermaster for me

 

[wolflarsen]

Old Dark Fired Ready Rubbed

 

[timt]

FVF

 

[Sonorisis]

Yup, Pegasus.

 

[edger]

It wouldn’t be one technically. PS LNF/LTF mixed 50/50 unlimited and you could put me on a desert island with a few nubile tobacconists and I would sift sand and swim happily.

 

[Duke of Erinmore]

Erinmore Flake in the original Murray's version.

If it should be a blend currently available, HU Daddy Gefftl.

 

[cshubhra]

The only reason I would smoke a single blend is when only a single blend is available to purchase.

So you see I don’t have a choice. I would smoke the only blend that is available

 

[warren]

I suppose whatever is available. I can't fathom only one blend being all that is available though.

 

[pantsBoots]

FVF or BBF.

 

[brandaves]

Such a hard question to answer. I would probably have to say Escudo or maybe aged LNF. There are a number of blends I prefer, but they’re not all day blends for me. So it’s an interesting question that’s distinct from “What’s your favorite blend?”

Regardless of my choice, I think I would get bored smoking the same blend always.

I was thinking the exact same two blends when I read this thread. Escudo or LNF for sure. I've purchased 22 tins of Escudo this year alone...I wait for sales then buy em 10 at a time. LNF is in the same vein. Love it.