If You Could Only Smoke One Tobacco For The Rest of Your Life...

[tomatamot]

Will let you know when ever the time will be right.

 

[tobefrank]

Orlik Golden Sliced for me I think, and I don't even have any anymore. ?

 

[judcole]

Can't pick just one. Don't want to try. Variety is the spice of life.

 

[scloyd]

Presbyterian or John Cotton's Smyrna

 

[puff_not_snuff]

Newminster 400

 

[jcsoldit]

I hope it never comes to that, but if it did my choice would be Marlin Flake.

 

[Gecko]

It would probably have to be SG Lakeland Dark or C&D Billy Budd.
Both are rich, lovely, stinky in a good way with a decent amount of lady N and complex enough flavors to hopefully not become boring or monotone after a few years.

 

[paulfg]

GH Dark Flake Scented,SG 1792 or old Irish produced Condor any of these would keep me happy

 

[smokiespipesmoker123]

Honestly? Plum Pudding, even if it does smell like a horse stall

 

[cosmicfolklore]

If I could only smoke just one tobacco... I'd quit. Sure, sure... there are some great tobaccos out there, but even Neo-Essoterica Blow your Mind Best Unicorn in the Garden of Eden is going to get boring to me if I have only it to chose from. Give me my high octane nic hitters before bed, some latakia in the winter, and an occasional non-goopy aromatic. Otherwise, I'll just grow my own.

 

[timt]

If I could only smoke just one tobacco... I'd quit. Sure, sure... there are some great tobaccos out there, but even Neo-Essoterica Blow your Mind Best Unicorn in the Garden of Eden is going to get boring to me if I have only it to chose from. Give me my high octane nic hitters before bed, some latakia in the winter, and an occasional non-goopy aromatic. Otherwise, I'll just grow my own.

Surrrre. I believe you. ?

 

[J.GANDY]

Haunted bookshop. I hope it never goes away.

 

[Jaylotw]

Old Gowrie or Chelsea Morning. I could pick either one. Both flip all the right switches.

 

[haparnold]

Maybe this indicates my palate isn't choosy enough, but honestly there's quite a few tobaccos which could be my only smoke, if necessary. Westminster, HH Pure Virginia, ODF, Three Friars, AP Rimboche, Dark Flake, etc.

I love variety. I love changing my smokes with the season (just cracked open some lovely aged Samarra for fall), but I could easily be a one-blend guy, if I had to be.

 

[DAR]

I love these kind of threads on forums. I've never had the same answer twice. Today it's Mac Barens Virginia #1. Just-one-tobacco tomorrow will be C&D Night Train. The next day it'll be Kingfisher and the list goes on...... and on.....

 

[Ahi Ka]

Haunted bookshop or ennerdale

 

[wyfbane]

I love these kind of threads on forums. I've never had the same answer twice. Today it's Mac Barens Virginia #1. Just-one-tobacco tomorrow will be C&D Night Train. The next day it'll be Kingfisher and the list goes on...... and on.....

Agreed. My answer was sort of my standard one. I love the navy flake. But reading everyone elses choice, I am like, Yeah! I love that one, too! And that one! And that one!

Hope I never am forced to smoke just one blend.

 

[Civil War]

I have more tobacco than I can smoke in a lifetime, but I keep going back to Cornell & Diehl - Bayou Morning.

 

[timt]

Obviously variety is ideal and that's why I have dozens of blends. But I like the question too - every time someone asks. My choice, FVF, is one of many I could live with and even though it's my choice and most heavily stocked blend, I haven't smoked it for several weeks. No particular reason other than boredom prevention I suppose.

 

[kg.legat0]

I'd probably just shred up Newports or Kools, paper, filter, and all, and smoke it out of a 4' bong while I plot revenge against the Orwellian despot who commandeered the world's pipe tobacco supply...

Really though, hard to say if it'd be Mac Baren Scottish Mixture, PS LNF, or Orlik Golden Sliced.