If You Could Only Have 7 Tobaccos.. Which Ones Are They?

[troyniss]

CD Briar Fox
CD Sunset Harbor Flake
GLP Fillmore
GLP Stonehenge Flake
New Minster no.400 SNF
Prince Albert
1Q

 

[Simmerdown☕️]

This is always a hard question to answer, but here ya go....
1. Peter Heinrich’s Curly Block
2. SG St. James Flake
3. C&D Haunted Bookshop
4. Revor Plug
5. Esoterica Dorchester
6. Germain’s Rich Dark Flake
7. Condor Long Cut

I limited my list to blends that are readily available or at least reasonably attainable.️

 

[coming to_falling too]

This is always a hard question to answer, but here ya go....
1. Peter Heinrich’s Curly Block
2. SG St. James Flake
3. C&D Haunted Bookshop
4. Revor Plug
5. Esoterica Dorchester
6. Germain’s Rich Dark Flake
7. Condor Long Cut

I limited my list to blends that are readily available or at least reasonably attainable.

I would love to find anything from Germain. What's your secret? Order from across the pond?

 

[Simmerdown☕️]

I would love to find anything from Germain. What's your secret? Order from across the pond?

?? Buddies, established BM relationships, & occasionally lucky on drops.️

 

[Lonely_wanderer]

C&D Black Frigate
Lane Vanilla Black Cavendish
Capstan Blue Flake
C&D Pirate Kake
Stokkebye Navy Flake
MacBaren Dark Twist
Captain Black Dark

 

[puff_not_snuff]

Germain's Rich Dark Flake,
Rattray's Marlin Flake,
SG Squadron Leader,
SG ST. James Plug,
SG Kendal Plug and
Dunhill Navy Rolls.

There's six there. I'd also take a floral lakeland, probably GH Kendal Flake, they're not something I smoke often but a floral blend with the sun on your back is one of the joys of summer.

I just had my first bowl of Kendal Plug, was really windy out so that made it hard to enjoy. I enjoyed it but didn’t blow me away. How do those who like both this and SG Brown Sugar say they compare if they do at all?

 

[stokesdale]

1. Virginia
2. Virginia
3. Virginia
4. Did I mention Virginia?
5. Wait, I meant Virginia
6. Maybe some Virginia
7. Oh, I forgot Virginia

 

[cachimbero]

Available:
Hal O´the Wynd
Old Gowrie
Nightcap
HH Old Dark fired
Old Dublin.
Skipper´s Flake.
Red Raparee.
Not available:
My Mixture 73.
HH Acadian Perique

Of course, this is the opinion of the day. Ask me tomorrow.

 

[petes03]

McClelland Blue Mountain
Orlik Golden Sliced
Hearth & Home Mazatec
McClelland Frog Morton (any of them)
Stokkeby Luxury Bullseye Flake
Mac Baren HH Old Dark Fired
Butera Pelican

 

[cigrmaster]

For the current week these are my favorites.
2013 Brigham Klondike Gold
2012 Rotary Navy Cut
2012 Fribourg & Treyer Cut Virginia Plug and Special Brown Flake
2006 Orlik Dark Strong Kentucky
2007 Stonehaven
2011 Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls

 

[philobeddoe]

These aren’t the seven I smoke the most, but if I were to be restricted to only seven for all eternity, I would need some variety.

1) Margate
2) Wilderness
3) McClellands 40th Anniversary
4) Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls
5) Solani Aged Burley Flake
6) Condor Ready Rubbed
7) Peter Heinrich’s Dark Strong Flake

 

[sablebrush52]

For the current week these are my favorites.
2013 Brigham Klondike Gold
2012 Rotary Navy Cut
2012 Fribourg & Treyer Cut Virginia Plug and Special Brown Flake
2006 Orlik Dark Strong Kentucky
2007 Stonehaven
2011 Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls

Hmmmm...Klondike Gold. I haven't smoked that in a while. Time to open a tin.

 

[Pipelady20]

I'm still new at this, but have really enjoyed these and plan on getting more (except #1). Of course this list will change.

1) Frog Morton Cellar
2) GLPease Quiet Nights
3) Carter Hall
4) Lane 1-Q
5-7) to be determined

 

[cigrmaster]

Hmmmm...Klondike Gold. I haven't smoked that in a while. Time to open a tin.

Jesse, I needed to search a couple of places but then score, there was around 25 tins sitting there waiting on my grubby paws. I smoked some earlier today and it was awesome. I hadn't smoked any in a couple of moths so it tasted really good. I am so glad O hadn't buried too many in the boxes they were shipped in cause I haven't opened shit

 

[davet]

1 Peterson 3P's
2 Wessel Gold Brick Plug
3 Salty Dogs Plug
4 SG's Bothy Flake
5 SG's Navy Flake
6 Peterson University Flake
7 C&D Bayou Morning

 

[NomadOrb]

I thought it would be fun to list the most commonly mentioned, still available blends that all of you have shared so far.

1. HH ODF
2. SG FVF
3. Escudo
4. OGS
5. HU Director's Cut
6. SG St. James flake

There was a huge tie for the last spot. Black Frigate, SG Cabbie's Mixture, Hal O' the Wynd, Marlin Flake, SG Squadron Leader, and Capstan Blue.

Gawith Dark Flake would have been higher, but some didn't specify unscented or scented.

Don't go too hard on me, I have too much free time.

 

[docpierce]

HU's Edward G
Patton's Stormfront
C&D's Baily's Front Porch
MacBaren's Mixture Scottish
Dan's Salty Dogs
Hearth & Home Ani Flake
C&D's Haunted Bookshop

 

[alaskanpiper]

I thought it would be fun to list the most commonly mentioned, still available blends that all of you have shared so far.

1. HH ODF
2. SG FVF
3. Escudo
4. OGS
5. HU Director's Cut
6. SG St. James flake

There was a huge tie for the last spot. Black Frigate, SG Cabbie's Mixture, Hal O' the Wynd, Marlin Flake, SG Squadron Leader, and Capstan Blue.

Gawith Dark Flake would have been higher, but some didn't specify unscented or scented.

Don't go too hard on me, I have too much free time.

Haha wow. Latakia is nowhere to be seen! As such, that list is totally unacceptable!

 

[RedZeppelin]

I'm so new at this, I don't think I could rattle off 7. But I'd go with:
1. Match 20
2. PS Bullseye
3. Luxury Navy Flake
4. Match Elizabethan
5. Rattray's No. 7
6. Wish I had more 965
7. PS 306 English - I like

 

[NomadOrb]

Haha wow. Latakia is nowhere to be seen! As such, that list is totally unacceptable!

VaPers are definitely well represented! It seems like many of the English blends got split up a bunch. They may be too subtlety varied to different smoker's tastes.

I guess a really well done VaPer stands out more than other types of blends.