If You Could Only Have 4...

[johnp]

Which four tobaccos would you pick if that was all you could have?
I'm thinking a Virginia (Dunhill Flake), an English (maybe Dunhill early morning pipe?), an aromatic (1-Q?), and maybe a va/per (Escudo or Redwoods?) Or maybe Frog Morton Cellar...

 

[cortezattic]

Mac Baren Virginia #1

SG/ St. James Flake

Pease Haddo's Delight

Escudo

 

[trailspike48]

I've only been smokine a pipe for 4 months. If I put down my favorite 4 they would probably be different next month. But for now my favorite is Mac Barren, Golden Extra.

 

[tjameson]

MacB Old Dark Fired

Escudo

MacB Burley London Blend

H&H Black House

 

[redbeard]

I haven't been smoking that long and have not really tried much but I could pick four.
LBF

Black Gold Plus- aero w/ Virginia flake, burley and cavendish

Snowflake - aero w/ Kentucky burley and cavendish

Seven Leaves- "Black Cavendish and Burley blended with top-grade Virginias – (Seven Leaves altogether)"
Think I may like the burley?? Lol

 

[hedonaut]

Stonehaven, Old Joe Krantz, Full Virginia Flake, and Charing Cross. Though these tend to change on a week to week basis. Embarcadero would probably be a contender as well as Dark Flake U/S and Bob's Chocolate Flake.

 

[alancairns]

Hmmm. Pease Haddo's Delight, Solani Va/Per 633, Capstan Navy Cut Medium, Dunhill Virginia Flake.
Alan

 

[gnatjulio]

PS Luxury Bullseye Flake

EMP

Nightcap

McC Town Topic
Tho i still love my Blackhouse and VaPer Flakes

 

[bigmick]

PS Luxury Twist Flake

SG Balkan Flake

McB's Golden Extra/London Burley (can't find enough difference between them to decide which)

HH Vintage Syrian

 

[chopsie]

Virginia - Mick McQuaid Plug

English - Dunhill Nightcap

Aromatic - McBaren Vanilla Cream Flake

Va/Per - Peterson Irish Oak (Just edged out Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls)

 

[bentmike]

Mac B Old Dark Fired

Mac B Vanilla Cream Flakes

Erinmore Flakes

Peterson's Old Dublin
I could probably live out my days happily with these four.

 

[tokerpipes]

Too many to decide. Of course I have been stuck smoking Super Value for the last year.

 

[crpntr1]

FVF

1Q

Escudo

FVF

 

[puffdaddy]

The choices tend to shift around a little, but if I had to choose right now, I'd say:
Virginia: GH & co curly cut regular

Aromatic: GH & co Conniston cut plug unscented

English: 3 Oaks Syrian

Burley: Uhle's 00

 

[phred]

Also a noob, so choices are subject to additional experience...
1Q

Vermont Meat Candy

Black House

PS Luxury Bullseye Flake

 

[05venturer]

Scotty's Butternut Burley

Carter Hall

Black House

Altadis Midnight Smoke
For now LOL

 

[homeatsea]

Dunhill Flake

MacBaren 7 Seas Regular

McClelland Scottish Woods

Orlik Golden Slice
Subject to change, obviously.

 

[salewis]

SG Full Virginia Flake

Dunhill Virginia Flake

Dunhill London Mixture

GLP Lagonda

 

[kanaia]

Luxury Bullseye Flake

St. James Flake

Magnum Opus

Limerick

Of course that could change next week.

 

[teufelhund]

MacBaren 7 Seas Regular

McClelland Deep Hollow

4th Generation 1897

McClelland Frog Morton's Cellar