If You Could Only Have 4...

[pstlpkr]

1Q

PS LBF

Haddo's Delight

Blending Perique

::

 

[kenoshakid]

It'll probably change at some point soon, but...
Haddo's Delight

Penzance

3 Oaks Syrian

Nightcap

 

[krizzose]

Mac Baren Club Blend

Mac Baren Navy Flake

Escudo

PS Luxury Twist Flake

 

[plet]

Virginia - FVF

English - Dunhill Nightcap

Aromatic - Petersons connoisseur's choice

Va/Per - LBF

-----------

Dark fired/Kentucky - Revor Plug

VaBur - Stonehaven

 

[bigboi]

Ahhh for me right now it would be
Mac Baren Vanilla Cream Flake

McClellands Frog Morton on the Town (I have original and cellar just haven't cracked them yet)

1-Q

PS LBF

Though OGS would be in the hunt as well.

 

[foggymountain]

Bombay Court, Frog Morton, Nightcap, and I am keeping the 4th secret because it is already near impossible to get.

 

[bobpnm]

Carter Hall

McClelland 5100

Frog Morton Cellar

H&H Classic Burley Kake

 

[judcole]

Screw the Va/Per and the aro
MacB HH Vintage Syrian

Peterson Old Dublin

McCranie Murdock's Pipe

McCranie Red Ribbon

SG BBF
Yeah, it's 5. So? :nana:

 

[andrew]

EMP

McClellands Dominican Maduro Glory

PS luxery bullseye flake

MM965

 

[tslex]

FMOTT

Penzance

Squadron Leader

and . .. .
oh this is tough . . .
Presbyterian.
whew.

 

[rosney]

Hmm...

Erik Nording's Hunters Blend Beagle

Mclellands 221b Honeydew

Dunhil Nightcap

Peterson's Holiday Blend

 

[tanless1]

That's tough...

Perhaps escudo , or glp navigator

Glp key largo

Mccleland Ynignie supreme

And maybe some golden dansk.

 

[ffmurray]

Dunhill's Nightcap

McClelland's oriental # 8

Lane's 1q

SG finest brown flake
I hope such a fate never befalls me

 

[oklansas]

Thanks everybody!
You all really helped fill out my list of tobaccos to acquire in the future - really want to try sg brown flake and erinmore!
In the meantime, as still quite a novice, really only have two favorites:

- McB navy flake

- G-Town Tobacco Reverie (I hear tell it may be a 1Q?)
I also tried Peterson Old Dublin - it was meh. In retrospect, it was probably too wet when I smoked it.

 

[uberam3rica]

Esoterica Margate, Frog Morton On The Bayou, Spartans English, and AJ's VaPer

 

[lordofthepiperings]

Lane Limited's 1Q

Peterson's Connoisseur's Choice

Mac Baren's Vanilla Cream Flake

McClelland's Town Topic

 

[erichbaumer]

Nightcap

Westminster

SOTE flake

Billy Budd, though Dunhill 965 almost took this spot.

Still lots to try though. I have yet to open a tin of Artisan's blend, which will be my first taste of Syrian lat, and I have some VaPers on the way.

 

[cigrmaster]

I don't have a top 4 more like a top 25, but what I have been smoking a lot of lately are the following.
Stonehaven

Solani Sliver Flake

Rotary Navy Cut

Fribourg & Treyer Cut Virginia Plug.

 

[blade]

PS Luxury Twist Flake

Escudo

Mac Baren Dark Twist

Mac Baren Roll Cake

 

[durham270]

McClelland - 3 Oaks

Rattrays - Black Mallory

Dunhill - Nightcap
Dan - Devils Holiday