I definitely feel nicotine’s effects with pipes, it’s just a way slower onset than cigarettes or vaping, and the satisfaction lasts quite a bit longer. When I’m particularly craving nicotine, I’ll just inhale a few times while smoking a pipe and that usually sorts it for me.
Cigarettes deliver a wallop straightaway in comparison, but it’s short-lived and people who are used to regularly receiving massive jolts of Vitamin N tend to get cranky when they go without. Cigarettes also usually reek and the smell sticks to you in an unpleasant manner, while with pipes, at least you have blend options that are a lot less obnoxious. I smell like pipe smoke after a bowl, but it doesn’t have that stale, rank funk you get from manufactured cigarettes.
Vaping is a bit weird—you can satisfy cravings with it, but it’s kind of a pain in the ass, has a neckbeard stigma to it, and I feel like having to wrangle electronics, batteries, liquids, and all that is a bit goofy. If you stick with the low end, you’re paying out the wazoo to suck down cookie-flavored steam, and if you skip that and go to the higher end stuff, you can get a much better tailored experience with the tradeoff of extra complexity.
Pipes are my happy sweet spot. I get actual tobacco smoke, I don’t have to inhale it, I can pick the right pipe for any given situation, you get the same flavor variety as with vaping, it doesn’t smell like an Union Carbide plant had an accident, it scratches my “fiddle with things” itch, and all you have to do is stick a wad of tobacco in the big hole, light it on fire, and occasionally sip tasty smoke from the small hole.