I believe that the search for the next great smoke leads us all along the bell curve of try outs. I have seven ball jarred blends on my tobacco bar along with a box of about 10 bagged sample blends and four yet unopened tins including one Blue Mountain that I am allowing to age somewhat. I love latakia so I naturally gravitate in that direction and now and then smoke an aro with disappointment. I always keep plenty of Penzance in stock and I always compare every smoke to a bowl of Penzance. My point here is that I've been to the top of the mountain (on the bell curve) and I'm convinced that I'm decending toward fewer try outs, no more aros, two or three latakia blends like PS Balkan Sasieni, Beck's Ol' Limey Bastard, Sterling's American Patriot, or C&D Engine 99 and of course Penzance.
When I choose a pipe, it's usually a large bowled one and when I pack a blend I want assured pleasure delivered consistently meeting my expectations. I've been left disappointed with supposed new great blends that really aren't new and really are not great. My go to selections seem to be hard acts to follow and I've decided that it's more fun to smoke them than try to surpass them. I'm one pipe smoker whose no longer running around looking for new smokes. I'm definitely settled in with my blends, my bowls, and my scotch and I'm a happy guy.