Sable, other than the simplicity and convenience, does Halcyon wax have any advantage over Carnauba applied with a buffing wheel?
Do the two compare?
Both the Halcyon and Paragon products are not as long lasting as carnuba, and they don't hold up as well when hit with hot water, like when performing a hot, or warm, water cleaning on a pipe. The chief benefit is that a buffer is not needed.
In the wrong hands, a buffer can be a weapon of pipe destruction, softening details, wiping out nomenclature, etc, etc. I had 10 years of performing delicate restoration work on fine vintage jewelry, which occasionally employed buffers, and what's called for is a very light, nimble, and deft touch. Given what I've seen happen to pipes, that's a rare skill. With Halcyon and Paragon I can get the same gloss without using a buffer, and without gradually turning my 1922 Barling Motor Cap into a shapeless shiny blob.