How do You Decide on New Pipe Purchases?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

crusader

Can't Leave
Aug 18, 2014
399
362
Nebraska
Wondering on how others decide on a new purchase. My state of Nebraska is a desert of b&m's, so I have to buy online.

Beside makes/artists, what boxes do like to check off before a buy?
 

warren

Lifer
Sep 13, 2013
12,299
18,321
Foothills of the Chugach Range, AK
I never buy a pipe unfondled and closely inspected. So, no mail order. A pipe must catch my eye when displayed, fit my fist and the fit and finish must be impeccable, an fills must be correctly done. I prefer a bit of silver but, that's not a rigid want. And, any pipe must be bent to some degree or another or it won't catch my eye. I never "shop" for a pipe, per se, when I visit a shop. I simply scan the display. If nothing catches my eye ,,, I move along to blends or accouterments. Last pipe purchased was on a trip to Ireland some years ago.
 

crusader

Can't Leave
Aug 18, 2014
399
362
Nebraska
^^^^ This.
And only this.puffy

I'm Catholic (nominally). I like them in all sizes and shapes (well, not really. But you know what I mean)

B&Ms are non-existent in Sydney, Oz
I don't see that as an obstacle
Only brought up the bm cause I have heard alot of folks say they won't buy unless in person
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoosierpipeguy

OzPiper

Lifer
Nov 30, 2020
6,744
36,386
72
Sydney, Australia
Ideally it would be a great idea to examine before purchasing
But B&Ms have a limited choice compared to online stores

If concerned, only purchase online where there is a return policy
I have had to do that on a very few occasions only.
The vast majority of my purchases have been smooth sailing
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoosierpipeguy

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,210
60,610
I've gotten to the place where I resist pipe shopping to the degree possible, because I have a fairly large sufficiency of pipes. I have culled the herd about four or five times, to keep he numbers down. To date, I have not done commissions. I think about a third of my stable are artisan, artisan finished, or have artisanal features like a hand-cut stem. But I also have a distinct fondness for lower end pipes that are moderately or low priced, or on steep discount. Rigorous selection has made these turn out to be fine pipes.

When I go about buying a pipe, I like to shop widely without too much preconception. I only buy one pipe at a time, for focus. The process usually takes weeks or a few months. I develop a set of about five prospects, and narrow it down.

I have had some success at pipe shows and the local independent pipe shop, though at the pipe shop, I usually go back to buy a pipe after considering a group of them at the shop.

So I guess I am unusually deliberative. I enjoy that. I feel more committed and convinced when I finally make a purchase, and usually enjoy exactly those features I selected in shopping for it, and maybe some others.

I have a number of gift pipes that have almost all turned out well. If it wasn't love first sight, I grew to appreciate each of them. I don't think I have ever traded off a gift pipe or one I received as a prize.
 

jdb67

Starting to Get Obsessed
May 18, 2020
145
847
Albuquerque, NM
Dunhill. I love the F/T bit and shell briar and ease in targeting sizes I want with group number and how they feel clenched in my mouth. My last purchase was a group 1 for tasting smokes at my local pipe club. Also generally easy to get your money back if you do decide to unload one. If I don't buy a Dunhill I do tend to look for similar criteria so bit shape, fairly lightweight, and sandblast or similar to shell briar has served me well. I have other pipes but when I'm buying these days I stick to this plan.
 

Hillcrest

Lifer
Dec 3, 2021
3,691
18,868
Connecticut, USA
I bought 5 pipes this year. 1 was an estate Butz choquin calabash junior at a really good price because I wanted to try that shape and it look really good. 2 were 9mm filters because I wanted to smoke 9mm filters: a Vauen olaf bent egg (shape and filter 2 boxes checked) and a Barontini bent billiard 1/2 spigot 9mm (2 boxes there). 1 mm Mark Twain because everybody here was raving about cobs and I hadn't smoked one in many years; then I HAD to get a forever stem. 1 was a Savinelli Erica Fiamma 128 Billiard 6mm filter new old stock at 1/3 the price it sold for new back in the day - I caught that one 2 hours after it was listed on Ebay and thats why no one saw it.

So - shapes I want to try in sizes I like; innovations I want to try in sizes I like; deals I couldn't pass up (I'm never going to see this price again). But I am done buying pipes now unless something really unbelievable appears as I have more than enough for rotation but I occasionally look. Now I am looking at tobaccos. Pad to TAD. That seems to be how it works from comments I read.

1661995754562.jpeg
 
Last edited:

dcicero

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 23, 2019
591
2,886
Michigan
Wondering on how others decide on a new purchase. My state of Nebraska is a desert of b&m's, so I have to buy online.

Beside makes/artists, what boxes do like to check off before a buy?
Now basically shape and if its a Gigi. I used to look at length and weight and other specs, but the gigis I like are heavier than I would have bought if I was looking for specs. So it took quite a few pipe brands and shapes before I landed on what works best for me. Half bent, small to medium bowl, gigi.