Hi guys. I would like your opinion for MB HH Pure Virginia, and Dan Patriot Flake. Which of these two would you prefer, and what are the differences between them? Also how do they compare to G.L. Pease Union Square?
Thanks.
Thanks.
HH Pure Virginia or Patriot Flake?
- Thread starter john19
- Start date
I’m all in when it comes to Dan Tobacco and their VA’s. I have some Patriot Flake from 2010 that is an amazing smoke. Just dark fruit sweet, smooth and bready its fantastic.
The HH Pure VA I have is much younger, only 3 years old but its also a great smoke. Has more citrus notes with some bread and light sweetness.
I haven’t smoked Union Square I hear good things but I try to stay away from blends manufactured by C&D. I’m not a fan.
The HH Pure VA I have is much younger, only 3 years old but its also a great smoke. Has more citrus notes with some bread and light sweetness.
I haven’t smoked Union Square I hear good things but I try to stay away from blends manufactured by C&D. I’m not a fan.
All 3 are superb. I prefer HH Pure Virginia. Very sweet. Next would be Union Square. Patriot Flake is just an okay Virginia Flake to me.
You believe Patriot Flake is more dark fruit style?
Not to hijack the thread—feel free to PM me if you’d like to discuss this—but: It sounds like your not enjoying C&D blends carries over to GLPease as well. While I don’t tend to like C&D blends, I’m a big fan of GLPease. But I think that, with C&D, I’m responding negatively to a blending philosophy/taste level; with GLPease, I have much more respect for the blending and tobacco choices.
I’ve never once smoked a GLPease blend and thought, “Hmm, this tastes like a C&D product.” (And vice versa.) But it sounds like maybe you have? Just curious about what connections you’ve actually experienced between GLP and C&D blends. Or is it more a matter of principle: You’re not smoking GLP simply because it was tinned by C&D?
Both are high quality but I prefer the Patriot Flake. It's just subjective though.
The Pure Virginia has some stoving that gives it a darker taste and some added strength. You may like that. Patriot Flake is lighter and easier going in my view. Patriot is more of a blonde Virginia, while Pure Virginia has added depth from the stoving.
The Pure Virginia has some stoving that gives it a darker taste and some added strength. You may like that. Patriot Flake is lighter and easier going in my view. Patriot is more of a blonde Virginia, while Pure Virginia has added depth from the stoving.
I've tried 2 of the 3 (HH & Union Square) and I prefer HH significantly. I don't recall the distinctions about Union Square that were less than optimal for me, but HH easily wins this for me. I may be including this next inappropriately, but after I tried US I tried Montgomery (so I associate them in the noggin) and I was more impressed. Enough to order another couple 8oz tins for the hoard.
I would have agreed with you until I tried Chelsea Morning
The only problem with G.L Pease is prices. 11.90$ for C&D 2oz tin, and 12.96$ for G.L. Pease 2oz tin. Plus you can find easy C&D blends in bulk.
I didn’t say that’s what I do pay. I said I would pay that, if that was what it cost.
Of course you will pay more for a blend you love. But since G.L. Pease are made from C&D, I don't see the point of them being more expensive (that's why I gave the example of C&D). At least, bring them in bulk too.
This happens everywhere. Capstan is made by Mac Baren and is $18 per tin, while HH Pure Virginia is ~$13.
Different blends and labels cost different amounts even when made under the same manufacture house.
This seems to be a common misunderstanding. Yes, these blends are tinned by C&D. But Greg sources and ages his own leaf, which is not the same leaf as what you’ll find in a C&D blend. And, or course, Greg is developing his own recipes and approaches to processing.
Also, I think it’s easy to forget that Greg is a boutique blender working with small batches. That doesn’t typically apply to manufacturers selling in loose bulk. (I’d argue that GLP does sell bulk; it just happens to be in 8oz and 1lb tins rather than loose in bags.)
I guess I misunderstood. Sorry about that. Pease prices are not a problem. Just a small negative (for me), relative to other companies (same others, not just Pease).