I'm the same way. I've never had PS Natural Dutch Cavendish, but I really enjoy the cigarette-like taste and smell of the other two. I don't like actual cigarettes, though I used to smoke once in a while. The pipe is so much better.I could smoke happily until the end of my days (well, maybe not) with Haunted Bookshop, Old Joe Krantz and PS Natural Dutch Cavendish. All are a little plain, a little "cigarette-y" but satisfying in some strange way. IMHO, of course. ::