They say people taste things differently, and though I have't re-ordered it, and finished the tin two or more years ago, it was entirely different. No dock worker flavor. A slight aromatic twang, but tobacco forward. And the Perique tingle was distant. I smoked it fairly fresh, maybe six months before opening, but I went through the tin quickly so it never got jarred. Maybe mine was the odd batch, but it resembled none of the described experiences. Spell check always screwed it up when I mentioned it on Forums.