Pinaud Clubman was not for me. Old Spice is as powdery as I will go... The cheap bottle was also terrible, the neck cracked off when I was removing the cap somehow and I had to dump out almost a full bottle. Oh well, it would've taken me 3000 years to consume at the rate I was going.
I'm all about cloves, though, so I probably would've been better off with the Virgin Island Bay Rum for occasional cologne use.
(To me, they are all too strong smelling and harsh for aftershave)
This is treason to some, but so be it.