Frank Method of packing

[3dogpiper]

if it works for you. I think it's an o.k. way to pack. I find it's very consistent and that is good.

Thank you Bob. Some things I try don’t work out at all?

 

[3dogpiper]

^^^ This. I started out with a pseudo-Frank’s Method, and it later evolved into a scoop… and go method. Maybe I was just lazy, or in a hurry… IDK, but I’ve been using this technique for years w/success.

Whatever works best for you is the best practice?

?good note. Thank you

 

[olkofri]

They're awesome dogs.

None better. ?‍?

 

[Donb1972]

My Grandfather packed his pipe in a way very similar to the Frank Method. It seemed to work for him. I just stuff and tamp, no special method. The best method for you is the one you like best!

 

[mortonbriar]

Honestly, another hundred bowls and you wont remember which 'packing method' you are doing, its just an empty pipe that needs filling.

 

[anotherbob]

Thank you Bob. Some things I try don’t work out at all?

wrong attitude. You learned what doesn't work.

 

[anotherbob]

I honestly think the best thing about these methods is they give you a great idea of what a properly packed pipe should smoke and feel like.
I've noticed it's usually new smokers that like these methods. Why because after while you will have already figured out a way that works for you.

 

[frozenchurchwarden]

Is there a method that is superior?

No.

Of course most people will say "it's all preference" but I'm confident in the principle of packing a pipe with lateral pressure giving the most consistent burn because of uniform tobacco density.
The aim of the Frank Method is to pack your pipe like someone rolling a cigar, leaving the tobacco pressing outward in all directions, versus "three step" where you're just pressing down and inevitably creating layers of density.

In the end my preference is for the Air Pocket pack, which is just Frank Method with only the plug of tobacco at the top of the bowl and leaving the bottom empty, though it's not necessarily just loading the top of the bowl, with some finesse you can load a fairly tall pipe with a single continuous plug.

 

[3dogpiper]

No.

Of course most people will say "it's all preference" but I'm confident in the principle of packing a pipe with lateral pressure giving the most consistent burn because of uniform tobacco density.
The aim of the Frank Method is to pack your pipe like someone rolling a cigar, leaving the tobacco pressing outward in all directions, versus "three step" where you're just pressing down and inevitably creating layers of density.

In the end my preference is for the Air Pocket pack, which is just Frank Method with only the plug of tobacco at the top of the bowl and leaving the bottom empty, though it's not necessarily just loading the top of the bowl, with some finesse you can load a fairly tall pipe with a single continuous plug.

Interesting.. thank you.

 

[Morrison Jeremiah]

Have to smile and shake my head every time I hear about the Frank method.
Why complicate something that is so simple as packing a pipe.
Oh well, if you enjoy.......

 

[3dogpiper]

Have to smile and shake my head every time I hear about the Frank method.
Why complicate something that is so simple as packing a pipe.
Oh well, if you enjoy.......

I do I do

 

[olkofri]

Heh... the three-layer is more complicated than the Frank Method.

 

[Irish Piper]

I'm curious now... Does anyone have a link to this "Frank Method"?

 

[3dogpiper]

Heh... the three-layer is more complicated than the Frank Method.

?

 

[3dogpiper]

Heh... the three-layer is more complicated than the Frank Method.

I'm curious now... Does anyone have a link to this "Frank Method"?

 

[PaulTheScandinavian]

Shall give this a try, I'd presume this'll work out well with rough ready rubbed Mc Barens blends as well,

 

[Sweet Home Alabama]

I like using the gravity fill method. I scoop and lightly tap the bottom of the bowl on my palm. When it is at the top, I lightly finger tamp. It seems to work pretty well in all of my pipes.

I'll name it the "Importance of Being Earnest Method (IBEM) to provide a reply to @Chasing Embers ....LOL!!
"The Importance of Being Earnest, A Trivial Comedy for Serious People is a play by Oscar Wilde.

 

[Peter Turbo]

palm swirl all day

 

[Irish Piper]

As I live in Germany I suppose I must try this lol

Also interesting that he uses a jet flame lighter. ?

 

[SunriseBoy]

Yeah, it is a preference thing isn't it. Scott from Aristocob did a YT thing about he did it, and I find it is very effective.
I tend to cut leaf into smaller bits, tip it in, tap the bowl on the back of my knuckle, press it in firmly, then two more times. And, I regret to confess, I'm one of these characters that like things to work well.
So, thanks to Scott for sharing the way he does it because I've found it is nearly perfect for me.