I'm not sure if 5 Brothers will be a good replacement, it has a very distinct flavor. I like it but the best description I could give you is a barnyard taste. Like they laid down fresh burley in a horse barn with the straw, left it a few weeks to age then shoveled it up and bagged it :D
Try this http://pipesandcigars.com/thsaprpito40.html and this http://pipesandcigars.com/rygoprpito40.html
Both premium shag cuts that work fine in a pipe or a paper.