I have tried both and in my opinion they are not. The same with white knight. The taste and properties of BH and WK is much better , again IMO.
Disappointed with Match Balkan Sobranie
- Thread starter wolfman9
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Not a matter of opinion. All confirmed by Jiminks and Russ over the years. The only difference is the bulk has more exposure to air. Many of Sutliff's bulk blends are tinned under different names. Queen Anne's revenge is Barbados Plantation, Creme Brulee us Molto Dolce, etc.
Maybe now. The tins i have are from the first years. The BH tins are the Mclelland type. The WK are from the first batch. From that time , there is a difference. Certainly , most of the tobaccos i smoke are rather old. Maybe is the time they have been on the tin. The bulks , i tried them fresh and i found them to be different. It does not mind since i rarely buy tobacco. I guess i have enough for the rest of my life.
400 posts and 4 months. Unless trading is different than selling. Which it could be but I’m too lazy to read the rules, honest but lazy. ?
You’re probably right. I have been wrong at least once in my life…I think I wrote it down on the calendar.lol I thought I had heard/read that the B.S. and B.S. 759 matches was blended at pipes and cigars when I started buying them in 2013ish then switched to Sutliff some time after that. I thought Russ O. Had stated that, but I guess not. Thanks for setting that straight. Seriously!
Yeah, Russ created the recipes but they're manufactured and tinned/bagged by Sutliff.
I like a lot of their match Blends but this one just tastes like ashes. It arrived kind of dry so it's possible I got a bad batch. The 759 is better, I get the heavy taste of their vinegary Red Virginia. But I don't know why the bsosm match doesn't do it for me. I do love some of the Sutliff matches though.
I was plowing along reading this thread until I noticed BROBS had posted. Talk about old threads.
Haha sorry. I saw this and wanted to see if anyone else has the issues with it I do. What happened to BROBS, did he get banned ?
Although the nom de plume of BROBS is retired, I have it on good authority that he is still around but much more subdued and quiet. But then again, there are many myths - but few become legends.
I don’t know, I have both and they are similar, but you can tell they have a different Virginia base. The BSOM has red Virginia in it and on some days I prefer it. I think that in itself makes it a closer match to the real deal blend from way back. However, the Peretti’s is a sweeter blend with less Lat. I believe they are using the same Oriental leaf from Sutliff. I just cracked a tin of 2017 White Knight and it’s sublime. Royal is an insanely good blend as well.
2017 was prior to STG manufacturing White Knight. BSOM at that time was bulk White Knight while BS759 was Black House bulk. Then again, the post you quoted is from over 4 years ago. I despise Latakia now.
Wanna try the lj peretti first off!
So Sutliff made them before right, so STG changed it? I can't see an STG tin tasting as bad as this bulk bsosm.
Yes on both counts. BOSM and White Knight were the same blend prior to STG making White Knight.