Dan Tobacco: Holly's Non Plus Review

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Mrs. Zarnicky

Lurker
Jan 20, 2022
45
182
76
Montreal
Holly’s Non Plus Ultra – Review.

I remember it like it was yesterday. I had just turned 11. It was winter in the old country and my friends Nikolai, Vladimir, Stanislav and I were all armed with snowballs. We were all looking for trouble and adventure and we found it soon enough!

“Let’s go to Baba Yaga’s house and throw our snowballs at her”, I suggested.

“Good idea”. Nikolai shouted. “The old witch deserves it.”

Her house was a little more than half a kilometer away from us and as we approached, we heard her scream “Fire”!



We bounded into the house, laden with our snowballs, and stopped at the open door of the smoke-filled room. Something was burning alright; perhaps she had been careless with her pipe again. It was not the first time. There was no fire to be seen, only clouds of smoke and Baba Yaga smacking at the smoke with an old broom.



“Do something.” She barked.



And we threw all our snowballs into the smoke—I think we missed Baba Yaga and ran out of the house to the telephone box.



“Let’s call the police as well.” Vladmir said.



“And the ambulance”



“And Alexander Rozhenko, he likes fires.”





But we only called the fire brigade, and soon the fire engine came and three tall men in helmets brought a hose into the house. Baba Yaga got out just in time before they turned it on.



Did the smoldering carpet remind me of Holly’s Non Plus Ultra tobacco? No! It was the smell of one of the firemen who obviously forgot to put on his deodorant that day.

The memory haunts me to this very day.



I recently smoked Holly's Non Plus and my advice is: Don’t try it!
 

gamzultovah

Lifer
Aug 4, 2019
3,241
21,652
This is a review on TobaccoReviews.com for this blend:

The memory of this tobacco haunts me to this day. I have severed all ties with the person who insisted I try it, and destroyed the pipe it was smoked in.

Things I would rather smoke than this blend: -C4 -Donald Trump's hairpiece -The powdered brains of my own children

The only worse-tasting tobacco I've ever encountered was when a friend of mine took some chopped up pieces of a tree, put them in a bag, and gave them to me as a joke
.”

This is one tobacco that I will not be trying in the future.
 

mingc

Lifer
Jun 20, 2019
4,334
12,783
The Big Rock Candy Mountains
LOL! Back in early 2020, Steve Fallon had a couple of tins of Holly's Non Plus Ultra sitting on his shelves for the longest time and I bought one. This was my review:
OK, here goes. I was so scared from reading the reviews that I pulled out my tester corn cob for this for fear of ever contaminating one of my regular herd. But, I liked it!

The mix is well rubbed broken flake and the tin note was very appealing : fermented figs with a very slight citrus note. The tobacco was still pliable and packed and lit easily. Once lit, the predominant note was cherry, and under the cherry, aged Virginia. The smoke was very smooth, commensurate with its age. The topping not over the top. It did not require an inordinate number of relights.

The only demerit was a slight bitter aftertaste when I smacked my tongue. But it was not bitter to the extent of old codger burley, which makes me dump the bowl once past halfway.

If I'm to give credence to earlier reviews that this is the devil's own poop cabbage, the only conclusion I can draw is that age has mellowed this thing out and then some. But for the aftertaste, I'd say I really like it. Maybe the next bowl will be different.

I should say that it's not that I'll smoke everything. There's actually stuff that I don't like. For instance, I should probably give my Cross Eyed Cricket and Autumn Evening away. My Semois too. The last bowl of Haddo tasted like I was chewing aspirin while gargling IPA; bitter, bitter, bitter!

To think that this tin sat on @pipestud's shelf just waiting for me all these years!
Rejoice! Holly's Tin!! :: Pipe Tobacco Discussion - https://pipesmagazine.com/forums/threads/rejoice-hollys-tin.75491/post-36088391. In conclusion, it's better than most McClelland Sacred Cows I've tried.
 

JimInks

Sultan of Smoke
Aug 31, 2012
65,729
681,739
Jim, I thought Jesse was your buddy? ?☕
Here's the story:
A friend of mine sent me most of a tin of NPU, saying it's the worst thing he's ever smoked, and wanted to see what I thought. I decided to have some fun with him, and wrote a very praiseful review extrolling great virtue on the blend, and PM'd it to him. This drove him crazy and he doubted my sanity. He started talking on that forum about my reaction, and giving me quite a bit of jazz about it, which I knew he would do. When he did that, I posted the real review at TR, so when readers saw what he was saying what I told him, they could see what I really thought. That's when he realized what I did to him. :ROFLMAO:

So, I told Jesse what I did, and he said if it's that bad, then he had to try it. I said, "Friends don't send friends Holly' Non Plus Ultra." But, Jesse insisted, so I said, "Don't say I didn't warn you."

Some days later, after Jesse tried it, he called me up and said, "Well, I smoked of a bowl of it" "What did you think about it?" Jesse responded "I thought we were friends!!" ? :ROFLMAO: