1!
didimauw Moderator Staff member Jul 28, 2013 10,788 38,151 SE WI Feb 6, 2023 #21 1! Reactions: alaskanpiper
CoffeeAndBourbon Lifer Jun 18, 2020 3,980 14,092 Wilmington, NC Feb 6, 2023 #22 #2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
TheWhale13 Part of the Furniture Now Aug 12, 2021 803 3,428 Sweden Feb 6, 2023 #23 Easy, "1". Apple with a twist. The discreetely blue stem brings my mind to the seas, and it's just a very nice clean design, which still looks both classy and classic. The best one so far. (If that was my pipe I would designate it to Salty Dogs.) Reactions: alaskanpiper
Easy, "1". Apple with a twist. The discreetely blue stem brings my mind to the seas, and it's just a very nice clean design, which still looks both classy and classic. The best one so far. (If that was my pipe I would designate it to Salty Dogs.)
pipingfool Can't Leave Sep 29, 2016 369 1,482 Seattle, WA Feb 6, 2023 #24 I wouldn't be mad at receiving either one, but I think #1 does it for me a little more. #1 it is. Reactions: alaskanpiper
jpmcwjr Lifer May 12, 2015 26,262 30,385 Carmel Valley, CA Feb 6, 2023 #25 No. 1 for me. Reactions: alaskanpiper
F fireground_piper Lifer Jan 30, 2020 2,431 7,974 New Jersey Feb 6, 2023 #26 1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
BlueRidge Part of the Furniture Now Dec 24, 2022 688 14,516 Feb 6, 2023 #27 Number One Reactions: alaskanpiper
brooklynpiper Part of the Furniture Now May 8, 2018 697 1,556 Feb 6, 2023 #29 2! Reactions: alaskanpiper
Briar Tuck Lifer Nov 29, 2022 1,109 5,745 Oregon coast Feb 6, 2023 #30 I have to go with number 2. I'm really liking the bamboo on these pipes. Reactions: canucklehead and alaskanpiper
E Englomatic Lurker Jun 18, 2020 38 276 57 Central Virginia Feb 6, 2023 #31 #2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
agnosticpipe Lifer Nov 3, 2013 3,421 3,891 In the sticks in Mississippi Feb 6, 2023 #32 Number 2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
FurCoat Lifer Sep 21, 2020 10,439 98,005 North Carolina Feb 6, 2023 #33 I'm in with #2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
SBC Lifer Oct 6, 2021 1,673 7,876 Yoopsconsin Feb 6, 2023 #34 If we were judging stummels alone, I'd give it to #2. But I don't do boo, so I'm saying #1. Reactions: scloyd and alaskanpiper
bluegrassbrian Your Mom's Favorite Pipe Smoker Aug 27, 2016 6,758 66,427 41 Louisville Feb 6, 2023 #35 This one was easy for me. I didn't mull it over, back and forth. Just went with my gut. Number ONE all day. Reactions: alaskanpiper
This one was easy for me. I didn't mull it over, back and forth. Just went with my gut. Number ONE all day.
MCJ Can't Leave May 22, 2022 437 3,667 NW Connecticut Feb 6, 2023 #36 Number 1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
cshubhra Lifer May 11, 2017 12,385 142,909 NJ,USA,Earth,Sol,MilkyWay,Virgo SC, Laniakea SC, Feb 6, 2023 #37 Both pipes are beautiful. However since I have to select - It is #2 Reactions: alaskanpiper and canucklehead
kcghost Lifer May 6, 2011 15,138 25,747 78 Olathe, Kansas Feb 6, 2023 #38 I'll say #2. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Toast Part of the Furniture Now Feb 15, 2021 663 1,334 UK Feb 6, 2023 #39 Neither are among my favourites so far, but I'll go two this round. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Fralphog Lifer Oct 28, 2021 2,256 29,695 Idaho Feb 6, 2023 #40 Definitely #1! Reactions: alaskanpiper