PS Cube Cut is another great option. Five Brothers as well. And I've had good luck with Sutliff matches having never the pleasure of trying the originals. On their own merits they are a pleasant smoke. Some that might feel familiar, like deja vu. In a very very general nutshell, C&D do pretty interesting things with a "new school" take on the leaf. And Mac Baron is usually a pretty solid gamble, they are quality products that you much not care for at worst.
You mentioned no flake and no ordering online. That will lead you to whatever your local B&M carries, although some might be willing to special order for you. In that case, I would suggest a conversation with the gentleman behind the counter, and any patrons with feelings about the subject.
As the gentleman above felt remiss without at least stating his case for flake cut, I'd like to make a pitch for online shopping. Without knowing where you are or your situation (and, frankly, it's none of my business), online has never been more convenient or safe. What you trade atmosphere, instant gratification, and the good feeling of supporting local business for is price and selection. A can of Granger and 5 or 6 2oz samples is enough to qualify for free shipping.
But, as always, YMMV.
