My take is that Peterson drills them like that by design. It's easier to drill a straight mortise and then an angled airway channel to the bottom of the bowl. The fact that it functions as a sort of halfway version of the system reservoir is a possibly unintended benefit. Both my Aran 01 and my Kelly XL02 are drilled like this, both have a tough time with a pipe cleaner, and both smoke great. Bottom line is it's just how they are.
Brand New Peterson Aran Poor Drilling?
- Thread starter pylorns
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
This seems to be a 9mm filter pipe, but without seeing the tenon, I cannot say for sure, but the bowl was for sure drilled for the 9mm filter. All bent 9mm filter pipes are drilled like this, not only Petersons, but Stanwells, Vauens, Savinellis etc.
Actually the drilling looks to be very good in this bowl.
Actually the drilling looks to be very good in this bowl.
That's just the way Peterson drills most of their bent pipes, even the non-System pipes. I have 7 bent Petersons, all of which are drilled exactly like that, and they all smoke great! It does work very similar to their System pipes, which by design are drilled high in the shank. Because of this, most of them will not pass a cleaner all the way to the chamber. That being said, a lot of bent pipes in general, even some costly ones, will not pass a cleaner as well. The ones that will usually require some manipulation of the cleaner.
Now if you run into a straight Peterson that's drilled like that, something is wrong! All of my straight Petersons are drilled center of the shank, as any straight pipe should be, and they all pass a cleaner with ease.
Now if you run into a straight Peterson that's drilled like that, something is wrong! All of my straight Petersons are drilled center of the shank, as any straight pipe should be, and they all pass a cleaner with ease.
Petersons seem to be going through a rough time with quality. It's sad, the classic shapes still draw me to them, and so far I've had no problems, but it does make me hesitant.
Contact Peterson and see what they'll do for you. Good Luck!
Contact Peterson and see what they'll do for you. Good Luck!
Ok well if you're looking at all of yours and they are drilled the same, then its not an issue. My Peterson system works great -but an ARAN is not a system and these two are nothing a like.
That's not the slant I took from the answer to question seven. I know that they get briar from the usual countries and it may come sawed into blocks. What I saw at the factory were employees working with chunks of briar. I'm guessing that when Palmer spoke "the bowls are mainly from Italy . . . " it was in the sense that the material was from those countries.
I will ask a pointed question next time I'm visiting Peterson in Dublin. Unless, a member living in Ireland can come up with a clarification sooner.
I'm planning on going in April. My wife is in the middle of a battle with cancer so the date is "iffy" at this time.
I will ask a pointed question next time I'm visiting Peterson in Dublin. Unless, a member living in Ireland can come up with a clarification sooner.
I'm planning on going in April. My wife is in the middle of a battle with cancer so the date is "iffy" at this time.
It's not an unknown problem with Petersons. I have one or two like that. You'd think that after 130 years they'd get it right.
I don't know that is fact, though I have accepted it as that from speaking to the owner of Pijpenkabinet (Amsterdam Pipe Museum). Speaking to him he stated that peterson ship their briar already cut and drilled from what they claim to be Italy, though he thinks its actually Spain (not too sure as of why).
From watching this video of the peterson pipe factory in Dublin it doesn't seem to dismiss what has been suggested to me. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YgQrnGMGPA
EDIT: Just noticed dryseason91 confirmed what I had assumed, thank you.
After watching through most of that video it brings an important question to mind... I wonder what the Peterson Employee Discount is
+1 burl!!! Interesting video, I really enjoyed it! I would love to work there myself, especially if there was a good employee discount!
Well that video explains why my silver bands always come off. Since I reglued them with gorrilla glue I have had no issues. Why on earth would they think carpenters glue would bond metal to wood? Love my Pete's but this makes me shake my head.
@dochudson again I was asking the question - is this normal or is it a screw up - everyone's input puts us at the "its normal" route.
Its not an issue, never has been an issue, its how bents are drilled, can't believe so many pipemen think this is a flaw let alone say it aloud lol
I have three petersons, love them all. Two of them are curved being a Mark Twain and a Peterson Kinsale XL11. I haven't really focused on the drilling holes. Hadn't ever considered it a problem. The draw is fantastic, not much manipulation of the pipe cleaner needs to be done. No problem. I think if anyone is going to critique Peterson it may be over some of the more vibrant stains, but I suppose thats just me being picky.
If I attempt to directly answer your question: It is normal, and it isn't a screw up.
Put some tobacco in it and try it out. :
:
Also +1 on the working for peterson and the Employer discount!
If I attempt to directly answer your question: It is normal, and it isn't a screw up.
Put some tobacco in it and try it out. :
:Also +1 on the working for peterson and the Employer discount!
I've a Shannon XL-02, similar to the Aran version of the XL-02, and it is drilled exactly has the photos above. I never assumed it to be an error but intentionally done to create a well for moisture collection purposes. I do recall anoher customer at my B&M asking about cleaning and he was told to wick out the shank with a Q-tip; works for me. I don't fret the pipe cleaner pass-though test myself.
Hope I don't get flamed over this, but I have plenty of bents that are perfectly drilled and pass a pipe cleaner quite easily.
Us Forums members tend to think in terms of a perfect smoke. That's good. But sometimes, a pipe with
imperfections draws pretty well and can give years of satisfaction. If it ain't actually broke, don't fix it.
Some of my bent pipes pass a pipe cleaner, most of them don't. One or two of my quirky straight pipes
don't, but most (almost all) do. If you can take it apart and clean it, and it draws okay, and smokes well,
go with it. This isn't necessarily heaven, but now and then it feels like it.
imperfections draws pretty well and can give years of satisfaction. If it ain't actually broke, don't fix it.
Some of my bent pipes pass a pipe cleaner, most of them don't. One or two of my quirky straight pipes
don't, but most (almost all) do. If you can take it apart and clean it, and it draws okay, and smokes well,
go with it. This isn't necessarily heaven, but now and then it feels like it.
- Status