photoman, I buy pipes based on certain makers, some are artisans some are factory. I used to buy Castello's, and they were excellent smoking pipes. I have bought Winslows because I liked the style and then found them to be great smokers. I bought my first American artisan pipe which was a Rad Davis and have bought some of those. When I find a pipe maker I like, I buy. I collected British factory pipes for a couple of months i.e Dunhill, WIllmer, Ferndown, Ashton, Upshall, and really enjoy those as well. I am mow sticking to American artisans for a while because I love how they smoke and look. There are so many quality pipes out there, and some great deals on the estate market, so I won't be running out of options anytime soon. When it comes to reputation, I take that with a grain of salt, just because someone has a good rep, doesn't mean I will like his work. You have to find what suits you and what you like to smoke. Everything comes down to personal preference, what I may like others may not. Keeping an open mind is important, if I had not listened to bigvan about American carvers, I would have not found some of the best pipes I have ever smoked.