Shepherd’s Pie (English), Hunting Creek (English Aromatic), and Old Toby (Aromatic) are my faves. Also heard good things about Angry Cornishmen (English) Bag End (Scottish) Green Dragon (a VA I think), and pretty much all the aros are solid.
I have some Green Dragon, Kingsfoil, Rivendell, Second Breakfast, Bag End, and a new blend called Smeagol that just came in to try. I know a lot of folks also like their seasonal Figgy Pudding.
Shepherd’s Pie is the real rock star though, and Old Toby is one of my favorite aros. Good stuff.