I am sure all of you guys who know me know who I will recommend, Rad Davis. I have had Rad make me 8 pipes so far and everyone has been a joy. Working with Rad is very easy, you tell him what you want and if he can make it he will. He does not require any type of deposit up front where as most artisans do.
I own in total 19 of Rad's pipes and in all my history of pipe smoking, I have never owned more than 7 of any other maker before. I have smoked pipes costing 3 times what Rad's pipes cost and not a one smoked as good as a Rad. He is well known for producing world class pipes for an affordable amount of money. Yes you can spend more, but I do not believe you will get a better smoking pipe than a Rad. I own numerous other artsian made pipes from the likes of Bruce Weaver(2) Brian Ruthenberg(4), Zack Hamric, Scott Thile, Mike Butera, Stephen Downie, Steve Morrissete, Trevor Talbert, Jody Davis, and Tonni Nielsen all one each. All the others I would buy more of for sure except Tonni Nielsen. The one pipe I have of his needed alteration to make the shank dimension bigger as he drills them a little too narrow for my tastes. It is a fine smoking pipe now that is opened up.
In terms of up and coming makers, our own Zack Hamric is really getting good. I believe for the money, he is also making some great pipes and he is getting better and better by the month. I believe within a year he will be making pipes on par with the best of them. He has come a long way in a short time and yes I am biased because he is a personal friend of mine and we do hang out on a regular basis. I am one of his toughest critics though and will tell him to his face if I think he could have done something better.